Faraway Sag Harbor

Faraway Sag Harbor, set to open in Summer 2026, is a highly anticipated addition to The Hamptons' luxury accommodations, taking over the extensively renovated historic Baron's Cove property. While the "Faraway Hotel" brand does have a Michelin Key selected property in Edgartown, Martha's Vineyard, it's important to note that Faraway Sag Harbor has not yet received a Michelin Key designation, as it is still undergoing renovations and is not open as of late 2025/early 2026. The following review is based on past guest experiences at the former Baron's Cove, insights into the upcoming Faraway Sag Harbor concept, and general expectations for a property of this caliber in the region.

Overall Rating & Sentiment

Based on reviews of its previous iteration, Baron's Cove, the sentiment was generally very positive, with guests frequently praising its charming atmosphere, prime location, and attentive staff. Faraway Sag Harbor aims to build on this legacy with a reimagined experience. Given the brand's commitment to creating unique and locally-inspired stays, and the extensive renovations, future guests can likely anticipate a superb experience, though the Michelin Key status for this specific location remains to be seen.

Key Highlights

Guests consistently loved the property's waterfront location and proximity to Sag Harbor village. The seasonal outdoor pool with cabanas, comfortable loungers, and umbrellas was a significant draw. The friendly and attentive staff received frequent commendations. The appealing design, described as a blend of nautical charm and modern luxury, also stands out. Complimentary amenities such as free bicycle rentals and beach passes were also appreciated perks.

Room Quality

Faraway Sag Harbor will feature 67 rooms and suites, designed to feel "collected over time" with layered interiors and sunlit patios. Guests at the former Baron's Cove consistently described rooms as very clean and comfortable, with some offering bay or harbor views. The accommodations are expected to include luxurious touches such as Tempur-Pedic beds, Egyptian cotton sheets, hypo-allergenic bedding, and blackout drapes. In-room amenities typically include iPod docking stations, espresso makers, 48-inch flat-screen TVs with premium channels, bathrobes, designer toiletries, and complimentary bottled water. Some rooms also feature private gardens or balconies.

Dining Experience

The property will introduce Zagara, a new flagship restaurant inspired by the Amalfi Coast, designed to seamlessly transition from day to night. Previously, the dining room at Baron's Cove served fresh American cuisine for lunch and dinner daily, with breakfast and brunch available on weekends. Guest feedback on the dining experience has been varied but generally positive, with many praising the exceptional presentation, taste, and value of breakfast, and the quality of dinner. Some reviews highlighted the lovely coffee and pastries, and the attentive waitstaff at breakfast. The property also features a bar/lounge, coffee shop/cafe, and snack bar/deli.

Service & Staff

The service at the former Baron's Cove was frequently highlighted as excellent, with staff described as friendly, attentive, and helpful. Guests specifically mentioned individuals who went above and beyond to ensure a pleasant stay. The hotel offers a 24-hour front desk, multilingual staff, and services like luggage storage and bellhop. While most reviews lauded the staff, some isolated complaints regarding customer service have been noted in the past.

Location & Accessibility

Faraway Sag Harbor boasts a prime waterfront location in the historic village of Sag Harbor, offering beautiful views of the bay. It's conveniently situated within walking distance of the charming town, including the marina, shops, and restaurants. The Hamptons Beaches are also just minutes away. The hotel offers free onsite self-parking and valet parking, and free bicycle rentals for exploring the area. It's also a good base for exploring other Hamptons areas like Montauk and Shelter Island.

Value & Pricing

Pricing for a luxury property in the Hamptons can be substantial. For the former Baron's Cove, average room prices could range significantly, with some reporting around $405 per room on average, while others noted prices around $1000 a night for certain rooms, particularly during peak season. Kayak's data suggests prices can vary from $243 to $2500, with the cheapest deals typically found in February and December, and July being the most expensive month. A resort fee of 10 percent of the room rate is also applied. Guests generally perceived the value as good for the level of comfort and amenities provided, though some felt it was pricey for specific room types or perceived issues.

Common Complaints

While overall reviews were positive, some recurring issues mentioned by past guests of Baron's Cove included noise levels, particularly from air conditioners and refrigerators in rooms, leading some to turn them off at night. Some guests also noted a lack of certain bathroom amenities like shower caps or makeup remover pads. Communication from the hotel, particularly regarding penalties and fines, was sometimes perceived as unwelcoming. Isolated reports also mentioned potentially short-staffed periods at the bar, pool, and front desk, and occasional dining items being unavailable.

Sources

1. mvtimes.com
2. farawaysagharbor.com
3. hospitalitynet.org
4. hauteliving.com
5. humphreymunson.co.uk
6. bestweekends.com
7. michelin.com
8. boutiquehotelier.com