The Roundtree, Amagansett

The Roundtree, Amagansett: A Serene Hamptons Escape with Understated Luxury

The Roundtree, Amagansett, a Michelin Key Selected property, consistently earns high praise for its tranquil atmosphere, impeccable service, and thoughtful amenities, offering a sophisticated yet relaxed "home away from home" experience in the Hamptons. Guests frequently describe it as an "authentic paradise" and a "beautiful, well-kept" property.

1. Overall Rating & Sentiment

The general consensus for The Roundtree, Amagansett is overwhelmingly positive, with a "wonderful" rating based on numerous guest reviews. Guests consistently laud its "quiet luxury" and the feeling of being "completely cared for." The property scores exceptionally high for cleanliness (9.9/10), staff (9.9/10), and comfort (9.7/10).

2. Key Highlights

Guests are particularly charmed by the hotel's attention to detail and curated experiences.

• Service & Hospitality: The staff's friendliness, attentiveness, and willingness to go above and beyond are frequently highlighted. Many appreciate the personalized touches, such as anticipating needs like an umbrella before it rains.
• Design & Ambiance: The property, set on two acres, blends historic charm (some cottages date back to the 17th and 18th centuries) with modern, minimalist contemporary luxury. The beautifully manicured grounds, sweeping lawns, and peaceful garden create a serene environment.
• Amenities: Complimentary offerings are a significant draw, including free bikes, beach parking passes, beach gear (chairs, towels, umbrellas), afternoon tea and cookies, evening s'mores and popcorn at the firepit, and in-room Nespresso machines. The hotel is also notably pet-friendly, providing dog beds, bowls, and treats.
• Location: Its prime location in the village of Amagansett allows for easy access to beaches, town centers, shops, and restaurants, often within walking distance or a short bike ride.

3. Room Quality

The rooms, suites, and standalone cottages are described as tastefully decorated, luxurious, and exceptionally comfortable.

• Comfort: Beds are outfitted with Frette Italian linens, down comforters, and premium bedding, with a pillow menu available, ensuring a "heavenly" night's sleep.
• Design & Features: Accommodations blend rustic charm with modern amenities, featuring natural wooden floors, crisp white linens, air conditioning, flat-screen TVs with cable channels, and private bathrooms. Many include sitting areas, safes, desks, and complimentary minibars stocked with snacks and beverages, including Nespresso coffee machines. Some cottages also boast fireplaces. Bathrooms are well-appointed with rainfall showerheads, bathrobes, slippers, and designer toiletries (e.g., Grown Alchemist products).
• Variety: The property offers a range of options, from standard queen rooms to deluxe queen rooms, queen suites, and various cottages (one-bedroom, two-bedroom, three-bedroom, and studio cottages), as well as a two-bedroom villa, catering to different group sizes and preferences.

4. Dining Experience

While The Roundtree does not have a full-service restaurant for lunch or dinner, its complimentary breakfast and evening offerings are highly appreciated.

• Continental Breakfast: A "substantial" continental breakfast is served daily, with options for in-room dining, in the garden (weather permitting), or in the breakfast area. Guests can tick off menu cards for room service delivery.
• Afternoon & Evening Delights: The hotel offers afternoon tea and freshly baked cookies, as well as an "ice cream happy hour" and evening s'mores and popcorn around the firepit on the back lawn, with vegan and gluten-free options available upon request.
• Local Dining: The location allows guests to easily walk to various cafés and restaurants in Amagansett for lunch and dinner, with East Hampton also just a short drive away for more dining and nightlife options. Room service from a private chef-in-residence is also available.

5. Service & Staff

The staff at The Roundtree is consistently lauded as "amazing," "friendly," "attentive," and "helpful." Guests frequently mention feeling welcomed and experiencing a personalized level of service where their needs are anticipated. The "seamless" check-in process and dedication to guest comfort are often highlighted.

6. Location & Accessibility

The Roundtree is strategically located in the charming Village of Amagansett, Town of East Hampton.

• Proximity to Attractions: It is within walking distance of Amagansett Square (0.3 miles) and Amelia Cottage Museum (0.5 miles). Beaches like Atlantic Avenue Beach and Indian Wells Beach are approximately 1 to 1.3 miles away, easily accessible by the complimentary bikes or the hotel's summer beach buggy service. East Hampton is 2.7 miles away, and Montauk is 11 miles away.
• Transportation: Amagansett Station is a 10-minute walk away. The nearest major airport is Long Island MacArthur Airport, about 55 miles distant. Free private parking is available on-site, and EV charging is offered.
• Accessibility Note: It's worth noting that the property, with its shell paths and stepped entrances to communal areas, is generally not wheelchair accessible, and there is no elevator.

7. Value & Pricing

While The Roundtree offers a luxury experience, guests generally consider it to be worth the cost due to the high level of service, quality accommodations, and generous complimentary amenities. Reviews for "Value for money" average around 8.5 out of 10. Pricing can vary significantly based on room type, season, and demand, with standard rooms potentially ranging from approximately $700 to over $1500 per night. The inclusion of continental breakfast, afternoon tea, evening s'mores, and various beach and bike amenities adds considerable value to the stay.

8. Common Complaints

While overwhelmingly positive, some minor points of feedback have been noted by guests:

• Breakfast Variety: A few guests mentioned that the breakfast selection, while good, could be improved.
• Air Conditioning Noise: In certain rooms, there have been mentions of noise from the air conditioning units.
• Pet Fee: There is a charge of $50 per night per dog, with a maximum of two dogs per room, which some guests might consider.

Sources

1. booking.com
2. slh.com
3. thequalityedit.com
4. theroundtreehotels.com
5. expedia.com
6. hotelsabovepar.com
7. michelin.com
8. hotels.com
9. theroundtreehotels.com
10. theroundtreehotels.com
11. mrandmrssmith.com
12. kayak.com
13. hyatt.com
14. hilton.com
15. mrandmrssmith.com
16. myboutiquehotel.com
17. theroundtreehotels.com
18. hilton.com
19. youtube.com