W Edinburgh

The W Edinburgh, a Michelin Key Selected property, has quickly established itself as a vibrant and luxurious addition to the city's hospitality scene since its opening in November 2023. Known for its bold and modern design, exceptional service, and unparalleled panoramic views, it offers a distinct experience in Scotland's historic capital.

1. Overall Rating & Sentiment

The general consensus for W Edinburgh is overwhelmingly positive, with an average customer rating of 4.4 out of 5 stars on Marriott Bonvoy based on over 540 reviews. Booking.com also shows a strong rating of 8.7 out of 10. Guests frequently describe their stays as "outstanding" and "amazing," highlighting the hotel's ability to deliver the playful yet luxurious experience characteristic of W Hotels. The sentiment often praises the staff, location, and unique design, though the exterior architecture has generated some discussion.

2. Key Highlights

Guests consistently rave about several aspects of the W Edinburgh:

• Design: The hotel features a cutting-edge contemporary design, including mirrored ceilings, sculptural lighting, and interiors that blend bold colors with luxurious finishes. The unique "Ribbon Building" is an architectural marvel, making a significant impact on the Edinburgh skyline.
• Views: The rooftop W Lounge and Sushisamba restaurant offer breathtaking 360-degree panoramic views of Edinburgh landmarks like Edinburgh Castle, Calton Hill, Arthur's Seat, and even the North Sea.
• Service: The service is frequently described as "excellent," "warm," "professional," and "attentive," with staff often going "above and beyond" to ensure a memorable stay.
• Location: Its prime location in the St James Quarter offers direct access to shopping, dining, and cultural attractions, and is within walking distance of major tourist sites and transport links.
• Amenities: The hotel boasts exceptional facilities including a modern restaurant, bars, a spa with treatment rooms, and a fully equipped fitness center.

3. Room Quality

The W Edinburgh offers 244 stylish guest rooms, including 45 suites. Rooms are modern, clean, and elegantly designed, featuring air-conditioning, flat-screen TVs with streaming services, mini-bars, and kettles. Many rooms, especially the "Wow Suites," come with private terraces and expansive spaces. Guests appreciate the comfortable, often king-sized beds and high-tech features like digital controls for lights and curtains, and wireless phone chargers.

Bathroom layouts can vary; some "Wonderful King" rooms feature an open-plan bathroom area directly behind the bed, while "Wonderful Twin" rooms have a more traditional, separate bathroom. Walk-in showers, bathrobes, and MOMO brand toiletries are standard. While some find the design-forward bathrooms a bit compact or dark, the overall quality of fixtures and furniture is excellent.

4. Dining Experience

The hotel offers a notable dining experience, primarily centered around:

• Sushisamba: Scotland's first Sushisamba restaurant, located on the upper floors, provides a fusion of Japanese, Brazilian, and Peruvian cuisine. It's celebrated for its excellent food, attentive service, and fantastic views of Edinburgh Castle and other landmarks. Breakfast, served here, is a menu-style experience offering unlimited continental options (like acai bowls, granola, and Scottish oatmeal) and one hot dish. Marriott Platinum members and above particularly praise the generous breakfast benefit.
• W Lounge: This sleek, modern bar on the top floor offers stunning panoramic city views, cocktails, and a small menu of sharing plates. It's a popular spot for both guests and locals.
• Joao's Place: An intimate cocktail bar offering Brazilian-inspired small bites and curated cocktails.

5. Service & Staff

Service at W Edinburgh is consistently highlighted as a strong point. Guests frequently commend the staff for being "warm, welcoming, and genuinely friendly". Reviewers mention staff being professional, enthusiastic, attentive, and proactive, making guests feel valued and often treating them "like family". Early check-in, late checkout, and room upgrades are appreciated by elite members, though elite recognition has sometimes been inconsistent.

6. Location & Accessibility

The W Edinburgh boasts an "excellent" and "prime" location within the vibrant St James Quarter. It's connected to a large shopping center with various dining and retail options.

• Attractions: It's an easy 1-minute walk to the Royal Mile, a 5-minute walk to Waverley Station, and a 10-15 minute walk to major sites like Edinburgh Castle and the National Museum of Scotland. Calton Hill is also a short walk away.
• Transport: The hotel is easily accessible from Edinburgh Airport via the St Andrew's Square tram stop, and Waverley Station provides convenient train connections to other cities.
• Accessibility: The hotel offers wheelchair-accessible paths, parking, public washrooms, and registration desks, making it suitable for guests with limited mobility.

7. Value & Pricing

The W Edinburgh is positioned as a luxury property. Cash rates can vary significantly, ranging between approximately $420 and $800 per night, depending on dates and room type. Marriott Bonvoy point redemptions typically range from 79,000 to 98,500 points per night. While it is one of the more expensive hotels in Edinburgh, many guests consider it a good value, especially when using points or for the level of luxury and unique experience it offers. Booking a room with two double beds can be a good value for families, as this is a rarity in Europe.

8. Common Complaints

Despite the overwhelmingly positive feedback, some recurring issues and criticisms include:

• Exterior Design: The hotel's unique "Ribbon Building" architecture has been a point of contention, with some comparing its appearance to a "golden turd" or emoji.
• Inconsistent Elite Recognition: While many elite members receive upgrades and benefits, some Platinum members have noted inconsistencies in receiving upgrades or welcome amenities compared to Gold members.
• Noise: Some guests have reported noise issues at night, attributing it to hotel employees walking along corridors and slamming fire doors, or a noisy fridge in the room.
• Lack of Pool: Despite having a spa with treatment rooms, a plunge pool, and a sauna, the hotel does not feature a full swimming pool, which some guests find to be a missed opportunity for a luxury property.
• Bar Service: A few guests have reported slow or inattentive service at the W Lounge bar.
• Open-Concept Bathrooms: The design of some open-concept bathrooms, particularly in Wonderful King rooms, may lack privacy for some guests.
• Confusing Arrival: Some guests found the hotel entrance confusing due to its integration with the shopping mall.

Sources

1. theluxuryeditor.com
2. middleeasttraveller.com
3. headforpoints.com
4. youtube.com
5. michelin.com
6. marriott.com
7. marriott.com
8. booking.com
9. frequentmiler.com
10. travellinghan.com
11. verylvke.com
12. booking.com
13. youtube.com
14. hotels.com
15. edinburgh.org
16. edinburgh-hotel.org
17. reddit.com
18. squaremeal.co.uk
19. youtube.com