Hotel du Vin & Bistro Edinburgh

Hotel du Vin & Bistro Edinburgh, a Michelin Key Selected property, consistently garners high praise for its sophisticated charm, exceptional service, and prime location within Edinburgh's historic Old Town.

1. Overall Rating & Sentiment

The general consensus for Hotel du Vin & Bistro Edinburgh is overwhelmingly positive, with many guests describing their experiences as "Exceptional" or "Excellent." The hotel is highly regarded for its blend of traditional charm and modern luxury, creating a memorable stay for visitors.

2. Key Highlights

Guests frequently commend the hotel's impeccable service and friendly staff, its excellent location near major attractions, the beautiful and sophisticated design, and the high quality of its dining experience, particularly breakfast. The unique atmosphere of the former asylum building, subtly decorated with a contemporary and local style, also stands out. Amenities such as free, fast Wi-Fi are also appreciated.

3. Room Quality

The rooms and suites at Hotel du Vin Edinburgh are consistently praised for their quality, comfort, and distinctive design. They are described as spacious, well-appointed, and elegant, offering a sense of indulgence. Many rooms feature custom-made sleigh beds with hand-sprung mattresses, luxurious Egyptian cotton linens, and plush towels and robes. Thoughtful details often include monsoon showers and in-room roll-top baths. Furthermore, rooms are equipped with Plasma TVs, air conditioning, and sound-insulated walls, ensuring a comfortable and quiet stay. The hotel's knack for decorating its historic building with dark, rich colors and a sparing use of plaid is noted as refreshing.

4. Dining Experience

The Bistro du Vin is at the heart of the hotel, offering a delightful French-inspired dining experience. The bistro emphasizes fresh, tasty, and well-made dishes, sourcing produce from the Lothian region and local suppliers. Breakfast is a particular highlight, frequently described as "fantastic" and "delicious" by guests. The bistro serves a variety of pastries, cereals, and cooked breakfasts. For lunch and dinner, the à la carte menu features classic bistro dishes like confit duck leg, cod Provencal, and a selection from the grill including steaks. The hotel also boasts a mezzanine bar and a Laroche tasting room for fine wines, alongside a whisky and cigar lounge, offering a range of beverages. While most dining feedback is positive, some reviews mention inconsistent service or occasional issues with food quality.

5. Service & Staff

The service and staff at Hotel du Vin & Bistro Edinburgh receive consistent commendation. Guests frequently highlight the staff as "exceptional," "very friendly," "helpful," "welcoming," "kind," "accommodating," and "attentive." Specific mentions include efficient and professional service in the restaurant and helpful reception/concierge staff.

6. Location & Accessibility

The hotel boasts a "sheer perfection" location in Edinburgh's historic Old Town. It is conveniently situated near the city centre, making it ideal for sightseeing. Key attractions such as the Royal Mile and Edinburgh Castle are within a 10-minute walk, while the University of Edinburgh and the National Museum of Scotland are even closer. Shops on Princes Street are also just a few minutes' stroll away. Public transport options, including Princes Street Tram Stop, are easily accessible. Housed in a building that was once a poorhouse, asylum, and science lab, the hotel offers a unique historical setting.

7. Value & Pricing

While specific pricing can vary based on the season and day, Hotel du Vin & Bistro Edinburgh is generally considered to offer good value, especially given its luxury status and prime location. For a 1-night stay for two adults, prices can range from approximately £100 to £225. Breakfast is typically an additional cost, around £24 for adults and £12.50 for children. An optional visitor levy of 5% will be applied from July 24, 2026.

8. Common Complaints

While guest feedback is largely positive, some minor criticisms have been noted. In the bistro, some guests have reported slow or inconsistent service, and a few instances of food being described as bland, small in portion, or certain menu items being unavailable early in the evening. One review also mentioned a concerning incident of finding plastic in soup. Occasionally, guests have experienced issues with room amenities like non-working TVs or heating. It's also important to note that the hotel has transitioned to a cashless payment system.

Sources

1. booking.com
2. expedia.co.uk
3. hotelduvin.com
4. flyingfluskey.com
5. michelin.com
6. hotelduvin.com
7. tophotelsedinburgh.com
8. expedia.com
9. hotelduvin.com
10. squaremeal.co.uk
11. thefork.co.uk
12. hotels.com
13. trustpilot.com
14. michelin.com