The Roxbury at Stratton Falls

The Roxbury at Stratton Falls, a Michelin Key Selected property in the Catskills & Hudson Valley, United States, offers a truly unique and immersive experience. Celebrated for its whimsical and over-the-top design, the hotel transports guests into a world of fantasy and luxury, often described as "part Disney magic, part Grimm Brothers, and part Willy Wonka".

Overall Rating & Sentiment

The general consensus for The Roxbury at Stratton Falls is overwhelmingly positive, with many guests rating it as "Excellent" or "Superb". Travelers consistently praise its unique charm, imaginative decor, and relaxing atmosphere, making it a highly recommended destination for a special getaway.

Key Highlights

Guests consistently highlight several aspects that make The Roxbury at Stratton Falls stand out:

• Design & Theme: The hotel's most celebrated feature is its fantastical and meticulously curated themed rooms and cottages, which offer a full-blown sensory experience.
• Natural Beauty: The property boasts direct access to Stratton Falls itself, an idyllic waterfall accessible via a newly constructed trail system, providing a beautiful natural backdrop for exploration.
• Amenities: The Crooked Cabana spa, with its heated pool, 8-person hot tub, and dry sauna, is a significant draw, offering guests opportunities for relaxation and rejuvenation. The property also features outdoor fire pits for cozy gatherings.
• The Roxbury Experience: Guests appreciate having access to amenities at both The Roxbury at Stratton Falls and its sister property, The Roxbury Motel, which is located just two miles away.

Room Quality

The rooms at The Roxbury at Stratton Falls are central to its appeal, each designed with an extravagant and immersive theme. The property offers seven mansion rooms within an 1848 residence and five standalone Tower Cottages, some of which are duplexes.

• Mansion Rooms: These rooms are individually themed, drawing inspiration from the site's history, such as a re-creation of a blacksmith's shop or the "Mill of the Frozen Falls," an ice-white fantasy. Common features include en-suite bathrooms (some with clawfoot tubs), refreshment areas with a mini-fridge, microwave, and coffee machine, and scenic views of the mountains or Stratton Falls village. Mansion rooms are often described as a "kid-free retreat" due to the fragile antiquities.
• Tower Cottages: These two-story cottages also feature elaborate themes, from "Cinderella's Gown" (complete with a pumpkin carriage) to "Dracula's Fangs" (featuring a chandelier with dried bats) and "Superhero Incognito". They often include two bedrooms, soaring ceilings, screened-in back porches, balconies, and some even have third-level observation decks for stargazing. Guests have praised the cleanliness and creativity of rooms like the "Space Pod" theme.

Dining Experience

The hotel offers a complimentary continental breakfast, which guests find convenient and satisfying, often including fruit and coffee. While there are no full-service restaurants directly on the property, the Roxbury at Stratton Falls does feature an honesty bar. Guests frequently explore local dining options in the nearby town of Roxbury, with recommendations for places like Chappie's Good Food and The Watershed Roxbury.

Service & Staff

The service at The Roxbury at Stratton Falls consistently receives high praise from guests. The staff is frequently described as friendly, helpful, attentive, and outstanding, contributing significantly to a positive guest experience. Guests have noted smooth check-in processes and appreciate the hospitality.

Location & Accessibility

Located in Roxbury, NY, in the picturesque Catskills & Hudson Valley, The Roxbury at Stratton Falls offers a tranquil setting with convenient access to nature and local attractions.

• Natural Surroundings: The property's main highlight is Stratton Falls, accessible via on-site hiking trails. The Catskill Park provides a wilderness for outdoor activities like hiking, biking, fishing, and golf.
• Nearby Attractions: Guests can easily explore attractions such as the Catskill Scenic Trail, Plattekill Mountain, Belleayre Mountain, Hanford Mills Museum, and the Pakatakan Farmers Market. The Roxbury Motel, its sister property, is just two miles down the road, and guests have access to amenities at both locations.
• Transport: The hotel is approximately 3.5 hours from NYC. Free parking is available on-site.

Value & Pricing

Rates for rooms at The Roxbury at Stratton Falls can start from around $114-$148 per night, though prices vary depending on the room type and time of year. While some guests note the pricing can be "very expensive for one night", the overwhelming sentiment is that the unique experience, luxurious accommodations, and exceptional service make it a worthwhile and memorable stay. Many consider it to be a good value for the unique experience it provides.

Common Complaints

While reviews are overwhelmingly positive, a few minor recurring issues have been mentioned by guests:

• Shower Pressure: Some guests have noted that the shower pressure in their rooms was not the greatest.
• Room Lighting: A few reviews mentioned that the lighting in some rooms could be improved, sometimes requiring curtains to be opened for additional light.
• Weekend Availability: The hotel generally has limited weekend availability, suggesting the need to book well in advance.
• Booking Confusion: A few guests found the website tricky and experienced confusion when booking, not realizing there are two distinct properties (The Roxbury Motel and The Roxbury at Stratton Falls) located a few miles apart.

Sources

1. discoverupstateny.com
2. expedia.com
3. booking.com
4. booking.com
5. michelin.com
6. greatwesterncatskills.com
7. secretnyc.co
8. theroxburyexperience.com
9. biteworthyindeed.com
10. theroxburyexperience.com
11. greatwesterncatskills.com
12. theroxburyexperience.com
13. michelin.com
14. booking.com
15. google.co.ke
16. theroxburyexperience.com
17. hotels.com
18. kayak.com
19. uniqhotels.com
20. iloveny.com
21. google.com.ng
22. momondo.com