The Barnett

The Barnett, a Michelin Key Selected property in New Orleans, stands out as a sophisticated and stylish retreat that successfully blends contemporary design with the city's vibrant energy. Housed in a revitalized 1920s Art Deco edifice in the Warehouse District, the hotel consistently garners praise for its unique aesthetic, lively public spaces, and excellent dining options.

Overall Rating & Sentiment

The general sentiment for The Barnett is overwhelmingly positive, often described by guests as "fabulous," "awesome vibe," and "unique." Its selection for the Michelin Key further solidifies its reputation as a top-tier accommodation, recognized for its distinctive architecture, design, and high-quality services. While the overall experience is highly praised, some minor inconsistencies in service and specific room design choices have been noted by a minority of guests.

Key Highlights

Guests consistently laud several aspects of The Barnett:

• Rooftop Pool & Bar (High Five): Described as "incredible" and "fabulous," the heated rooftop pool area offers an amazing vibe with sweeping city views, perfect for sunny afternoons or breezy nights. It features a bar serving small plates and seasonal cocktails.
• Lively Public Spaces & Design: The hotel's lobby bar and other communal areas are celebrated for their beautiful French Deco-inspired design, vibrant ambiance, and often feature live music and eclectic DJs. The overall decor is a tasteful blend of vintage-inspired elements and local artwork, creating a "happening" atmosphere.
• Dining Options: The variety and quality of on-site food and beverage offerings are frequently highlighted as "incredible" and "delicious."
• Location: Its prime location in the Warehouse District offers convenient access to major attractions.

Room Quality

The rooms at The Barnett are designed to blend luxury with comfort, featuring vintage-inspired decor, plush bedding, curated artwork, and industrial accents such as exposed brick walls and polished concrete floors. Many rooms boast high ceilings, and some offer large windows with city views or private patios. Amenities often include complimentary Wi-Fi, quality bath products, and a retro fridge.

However, a recurring point of feedback concerns the open-concept bathroom design, with some rooms having a heavy curtain instead of a traditional door for the bathroom, and potential issues with water splashing from the showers. While some appreciate the spaciousness, a few guests have found certain "base King rooms" to be small and "super shabby" compared to more upgraded options.

Dining Experience

The Barnett offers a diverse and acclaimed culinary landscape with multiple on-site options:

• Brutto Americano: The hotel's signature restaurant, serving modern American fare with global flair for breakfast, lunch, and dinner.
• Seaworthy: An oyster bar and seafood restaurant set in an 1832 Creole cottage, focusing on sustainably sourced oysters and Gulf Coast-inspired dishes.
• High Five: The rooftop bar and pool offering light bites and seasonal cocktails with panoramic city views.
• All Good: A neighborhood-inspired café providing responsibly sourced coffee (Mammoth Coffee Company), teas, juices, and elevated café fare like beignets, quiche, and paninis.
• The Lobby Bar: A French Deco-inspired bar with Southern and Italian fare and nightly entertainment.

Guests generally find the food and drink options to be excellent.

Service & Staff

The staff at The Barnett are frequently praised for being "beyond friendly and accommodating," "helpful," "professional," and "courteous." Many guests highlight genuine hospitality that enhances their stay. However, some isolated criticisms include slow service at restaurants for breakfast and instances of unhelpful front desk responses regarding room changes or upgrades.

Location & Accessibility

Situated in the heart of New Orleans' Central Business District/Warehouse District, The Barnett boasts an "excellent location." It is within easy walking distance or a short streetcar ride to key attractions:

• French Quarter: Approximately an 8 to 25-minute walk.
• Canal Street: Minutes away.
• National World War II Museum: About a 10-minute walk.
• Caesars Superdome & Caesars New Orleans Casino: Around an 11-minute walk.
• Ernest N. Morial Convention Center: A 13-minute walk.

The hotel is surrounded by art galleries, high-profile restaurants, shopping, and offers easy access to streetcar lines.

Value & Pricing

Room rates at The Barnett generally range from approximately $126 to $928, with deluxe rooms starting around $189. The hotel is considered a Category 5 property within the World of Hyatt program, with award redemption nights ranging from 17,000 to 23,000 points. A daily destination fee of $25 is applied to each room. While many guests find the experience worthwhile, some have expressed disappointment if their room quality did not meet expectations for the price point.

Common Complaints

Despite its many positive attributes, a few recurring issues have been mentioned:

• Bathroom Design: The open-concept bathrooms, often with only a curtain instead of a door, and issues with water splashing from showers, can be a point of discomfort for some guests.
• Inconsistent Room Experience: While many rooms are well-appointed, some "base King rooms" have been described as small or "super shabby," and some guests have reported issues with receiving desired upgrades.
• Service Inconsistencies: Instances of slow restaurant service and unhelpful front desk staff have been reported.
• Noise Levels: Street-facing rooms on lower floors may experience significant noise from streetcars and general city traffic, with some noting a lack of soundproofing.
• Elevator Wait Times: Occasional long waits for elevators have been a minor inconvenience for some.
• Rooftop Pool Closures: Unexplained or early closures of the rooftop pool have been a source of frustration for a few guests.

Sources

1. thebarnett.com
2. michelin.com
3. tablethotels.com
4. travelzoo.com
5. hotels.com
6. booking.com
7. booking.com
8. neworleans.com
9. travelocity.com
10. thebarnett.com
11. flyertalk.com
12. neworleans.com
13. hyatt.com
14. booking.com
15. youtube.com
16. flyertalk.com
17. reddit.com
18. hyatt.com
19. expedia.com
20. neworleans.com
21. kayak.com
22. momondo.com
23. thepointsguy.com
24. youtube.com