Greydon House

Greydon House, a Michelin Key Selected property in Nantucket, United States, consistently earns high praise for its distinctive design, prime location, and exceptional service. Housed within a meticulously restored 1850s Greek Revival structure with a modern extension, the hotel offers a unique blend of historic charm and contemporary luxury.

1. Overall Rating & Sentiment

The general consensus for Greydon House is overwhelmingly positive, often described as "Wonderful" or "Exceptional." Guests and professional reviewers alike appreciate its sophisticated ambiance and attention to detail.

2. Key Highlights

Guests consistently laud Greydon House for several key attributes:

• Design & Ambiance: The hotel boasts an eclectic and layered interpretation of island style, featuring curated art, antiques, and custom furnishings by renowned designers Roman and Williams. The decor exudes warmth and timeless elegance, avoiding local clichés.
• Location: Its central downtown Nantucket location is highly convenient, making it easy to explore the island's best shopping, dining, and historic sites. The Whaling Museum and ferry terminal are just a short walk away.
• Dining: The on-site restaurant, Via Mare, is a significant draw, known for its Mediterranean/Venetian-inspired menu and Michelin-starred chef.
• Service: The staff consistently receives accolades for being friendly, helpful, and accommodating.

3. Room Quality

The 20 rooms at Greydon House are described as cozy and luxurious. Each room features custom furnishings, soft linens, and rich wood accents that subtly nod to Nantucket's maritime history. Some rooms even delight guests with hand-painted wallpaper. While not described as vast, the rooms are gorgeous and comfortably plush, equipped with Egyptian cotton sheets, pillowtop mattresses, blackout drapes, and hypo-allergenic bedding for a blissful slumber. Amenities include flat-screen TVs, air conditioning, free Wi-Fi, and bathrooms stocked with premium toiletries such as Acqua di Parma or Aesop products, and custom nautical scenes on Portuguese hand-painted tiles.

4. Dining Experience

The hotel's restaurant, Via Mare, is a highlight, inspired by the Venetian tradition of small-plate dining. The menu, crafted by London-born chef Marcus Gleadow-Ware (an alum of a Michelin-starred kitchen in New York), emphasizes locally sourced seafood and features a Mediterranean-inspired selection. Guests praise the exceptional food and service, noting perfectly prepared dishes like scallops and grilled pork chops. Breakfast is served daily in the bar area. The dining atmosphere is described as whimsical, with sea-blue walls giving a modern New England tavern feel, and dining options including the intimate dining room, a bohemian living room-cum-bar, or an open-air terrace.

5. Service & Staff

The staff at Greydon House consistently receives excellent feedback. Guests describe them as "fantastic," "friendly," "helpful," "super sweet," and "very solicitous and accommodating." Reviewers highlight instances where staff members went "out of their way to assist," contributing significantly to a memorable stay.

6. Location & Accessibility

Greydon House boasts an "ideal location" in Downtown Nantucket's historic district, making it "as good as you can get in Nantucket." It's conveniently situated for exploring the island's best shopping, dining, and historic sites. Attractions like the Whaling Museum are just a minute's walk away, and the ferry terminal is two minutes by foot, making it easily accessible and walkable to everything.

7. Value & Pricing

While Nantucket can be a high-end destination, Greydon House generally garners positive feedback for its value. Expedia notes prices starting from approximately $169.21 for a one-night stay for two adults (as of January 28, 2026, for a February 1, 2026 stay), though prices are subject to change. On review platforms, its value for money is rated around 8.5 out of 10. A past dining experience with three glasses of wine costing $210 was considered "quite reasonable" for the quality of food and service received.

8. Common Complaints

While reviews are overwhelmingly positive, a few minor points have been raised:

• Noise: One guest mentioned that the rooms are "not sound proof," suggesting earplugs for those sensitive to noisy neighbors.
• Restaurant Hours: A guest noted the restaurant was closed on Sundays during the shoulder season, though they found this understandable.

Sources

1. lesboutiquehotels.com
2. thehotelguru.com
3. michelin.com
4. interiormonologue.com
5. booking.com
6. greydonhouse.com
7. expedia.com
8. hotels.com
9. onekingslane.com
10. greydonhouse.com
11. foodscienceinstitute.com
12. nantucket-bedandbreakfast.com
13. tripandways.com