Torre di Bellosguardo

Torre di Bellosguardo, a Michelin Key One-Key property nestled in the hills overlooking Florence, offers a unique and memorable stay in a historic Renaissance villa. It is widely praised for its breathtaking views, serene atmosphere, and antique charm.

1. Overall Rating & Sentiment

Torre di Bellosguardo generally receives overwhelmingly positive feedback, often described as a "charming oasis," "magical," and "fairytale-like" destination. Guests frequently highlight its unique character and historic elegance. The Michelin Guide awards it One Key, signifying a "very special stay." Review scores on platforms like Booking.com show "Very Good" ratings, with high marks for location, staff, and cleanliness.

2. Key Highlights

Guests consistently rave about the hotel's stunning panoramic views of Florence, which are often cited as among the best in Italy. The property's rich history, dating back to the 12th-13th century and once owned by the Medici family with connections to Dante and Galileo, adds significantly to its allure. The expansive, beautifully maintained gardens, complete with olive groves, cypress trees, and a seasonal outdoor swimming pool, provide a tranquil escape from the city's hustle and bustle. The ambiance of old-world Italian glamour, featuring frescoed rooms and museum-worthy antiques, is also a significant draw.

3. Room Quality

The hotel offers 16 unique rooms and suites, each individually decorated in a traditional Florentine style with period furniture. Rooms are generally described as spacious, some featuring rib-vaulted ceilings, oriental rugs, dark wooden furniture, and jewel-toned accent pillows, aiming to evoke a sense of centuries-old charm. Modern amenities such as air conditioning, private bathrooms (with showers or bathtubs and hairdryers), flat-screen TVs, minibars, and safes are included. Some rooms boast magnificent views of the gardens or the city. However, some past guests have noted inconsistencies, with mentions of "old and worn out" rooms, dirty carpets, issues with bathtubs, or bathrooms not being "100% clean" with inadequate showers in older reviews.

4. Dining Experience

The breakfast experience at Torre di Bellosguardo is highly praised. It is typically served on a beautiful terrace with stunning views and is described as delicious, offering a spread of fresh fruit, pastries, cured meats, and cheeses. Guests can also order eggs and cappuccinos from the staff. The hotel has a bar and poolside bar, and a 24/7 bar where front desk staff can serve drinks. However, it's important to note that there is no full-service restaurant on-site for lunch or dinner beyond breakfast and light snacks by the pool. The estate's small organic vegetable garden provides fresh produce for breakfast and snacks.

5. Service & Staff

The service and staff receive consistent acclaim for being friendly, helpful, attentive, and impeccable. Guests often highlight the personalized and professional nature of the hospitality, making them feel at ease and at home. The staff's welcoming demeanor contributes significantly to the overall positive guest experience.

6. Location & Accessibility

Perched on a hillside in the Oltrarno district, Torre di Bellosguardo offers an idyllic, serene setting away from the crowded city center, while still providing magnificent views of Florence. It's located about a 15-minute uphill walk from the city, or a 10-minute taxi ride to central attractions like Pitti Palace and Boboli Gardens. While walkable to certain areas, a car is often recommended for more convenient travel, as direct public transport links are not available. The hotel offers free private parking and an underground garage. Florence's Amerigo Vespucci Airport is approximately a 20-25 minute taxi ride away.

7. Value & Pricing

With average room prices around $361, compared to Florence's city average of $195, Torre di Bellosguardo is positioned as a more opulent escape. However, some sources indicate rooms can start from €190 or $223. Many guests feel it offers excellent value for the unique, historic experience and luxurious setting it provides. Conversely, some guests have expressed that the hotel can be "far too expensive for what you actually get," particularly when considering the lack of a full restaurant and some older room conditions.

8. Common Complaints

• Lack of On-Site Dining Options: The most frequently mentioned complaint is the absence of a full-service restaurant for lunch and dinner, meaning guests need to venture off-property for most meals.
• Room Condition Inconsistencies: Some past guests have reported issues with room quality, citing "old and worn out" decor, dirty carpets, or bathrooms with dated fixtures or inadequate showers (e.g., a wand over a bathtub). There are also mentions of "bugs" in rooms in some older reviews.
• Limited In-Room Amenities: A few guests have noted the absence of tea/coffee making facilities in rooms, or a lack of a mini-bar in some instances, though other sources suggest minibars are generally available.
• Unheated Pool: While there is a beautiful seasonal outdoor pool, one review mentioned it was too cold to enjoy in late September due to being unheated.
• Quiet/Empty Atmosphere (Off-Season): During low season, some guests found the hotel to be very quiet, with dimly lit hallways, which could create a "scary" or less "cosy and inviting" atmosphere.
• Accessibility to City Center: While appreciated for its peaceful location, its distance from the city center means relying on taxis or a significant walk, which may not suit all travelers, especially for evening dining.
• Architectural Quirks: One guest reported hitting their head on low arches, suggesting potential hazards in an older building.

Sources

1. agoda.com
2. booking.com
3. uproxx.com
4. hotels.com
5. yolojournal.com
6. trip.com
7. michelin.com
8. michelin.com
9. booking.com
10. lively-arts.com
11. torrebellosguardo.com
12. torrebellosguardo.com
13. thehotelguru.com
14. trivago.co.uk
15. torrebellosguardo.com
16. tuscanyaccommodation.com
17. tuscanyitalyhotels.com
18. torrebellosguardo.com
19. kayak.com