The Beekman - A Thompson Hotel

The Beekman - A Thompson Hotel, New York City: A Comprehensive Review

The Beekman, a Thompson Hotel, stands as a distinctive luxury property in Lower Manhattan, lauded for its stunning historic architecture, unique design, and vibrant atmosphere. Awarded a Michelin One-Key distinction, it offers a memorable stay that blends 19th-century charm with modern comforts.

1. Overall Rating & Sentiment

The general consensus for The Beekman is overwhelmingly positive, with guests frequently praising its beautiful restoration and unique character. It's often described as a "phenomenal hotel" and an "architectural gem," providing a unique experience compared to more "cookie-cutter" luxury hotels in New York City. While some minor issues, such as noise or room design preferences, are occasionally mentioned, the overall sentiment is that of a highly recommended and captivating stay, particularly for those who appreciate history and distinctive aesthetics.

2. Key Highlights

Guests are consistently captivated by several aspects of The Beekman:

• Design & Architecture: The centerpiece is undoubtedly the magnificent nine-story central atrium with its pyramidal glass skylight and intricate wrought-iron railings, which has been designated an interior NYC landmark. The hotel's design beautifully melds antique embellishments with chic mid-century furniture, creating a "dilapidated Victorian aesthetic" that feels both opulent and intimate.
• Atmosphere: The public spaces, especially The Bar Room under the atrium, are a significant draw, offering a "classic speakeasy kind of way" or a "John Wick movie" vibe. It's a popular spot for both guests and locals for cocktails and is particularly vibrant with live jazz on weekends.
• Location (Lower Manhattan): Situated in the Financial District, the hotel provides easy access to landmarks like City Hall Park, the Brooklyn Bridge, Wall Street, and multiple subway lines. This location is appreciated for exploring "Old New York" and offers good value for Hyatt points.
• Pet-Friendly: The Beekman is noted as a pet-friendly hotel with no pet fees.

3. Room Quality

The rooms and suites at The Beekman are described as stylish, unique, and comfortable, often incorporating an eclectic mix of bespoke and vintage items. Key features include:

• Comfort: Guests frequently praise the very comfortable king-size beds with leather headboards and high-end sateen Sferra linens. Blackout curtains are effective for a good night's sleep.
• Design: Rooms showcase a blend of historic charm and modern touches, with oak floors, quirky artwork, and interesting lamps. Some rooms feature a "dilapidated Victorian aesthetic" that some find appealing and others describe as "cold" or "sparsely furnished."
• Bathrooms: The bathrooms are generally well-received, featuring marble tiling, rainfall showerheads, and amenities by D.S. & Durga. They are often described as spacious and bright, with thoughtful designs like full shower doors to prevent leaks.
• Size: Room sizes are considered good for Manhattan standards, with junior suites and premium rooms offering ample space.
• Amenities: Rooms come with expected luxury trappings such as mini-bars, full-sized closets, and multiple flat-screen TVs in larger suites.

4. Dining Experience

The Beekman offers several highly-rated dining options:

• Temple Court: This signature American restaurant by celebrity chef Tom Colicchio is open for all three meals and also handles room service. Guests have praised dishes like chestnut agnolotti, steelhead trout, and braised rib ravioli. Breakfast here, available to those with certain benefits, is generally considered good, though some have found it "unimaginative and overpriced" or experienced slow service.
• Le Gratin: Chef Daniel Boulud's French bistro, inspired by his hometown of Lyon, offers dishes like Burgundy Snail Tempura and Spit-Roasted Chicken, and has received five-star reviews. However, it might be excluded from hotel dining credits.
• The Bar Room at Temple Court: Located under the stunning atrium, this space offers an all-day menu of cocktails, coffee, and light appetizers and entrees. While the "vibes are immaculate," the food here is often described as "decent but expensive" or "average given the price." Cocktails, like the Espresso Martini, are highly recommended.

5. Service & Staff

Service at The Beekman is generally regarded as "pretty good" to "incredible."

• Responsiveness: Guests highlight the staff's responsiveness to requests, with prompt action taken for issues like thermostat adjustments or room switches.
• Hospitality: Front desk staff and valet teams are often described as friendly and professional. Concierge services, such as delivering a welcome bottle of wine, contribute to a positive experience.
• Housekeeping: Twice-daily housekeeping with turndown service is a noted luxury.
• Inconsistencies: Some guests have reported instances of service being "stretched thin" or slow, particularly during breakfast at Temple Court. Housekeeping has occasionally missed replacing complimentary water bottles.

6. Location & Accessibility

The Beekman is strategically located in the Financial District (FiDi) of Lower Manhattan, offering convenient access to various attractions and transportation:

• Attractions: It's just a block from City Hall Park, near the Manhattan entrance to the Brooklyn Bridge (a 10-minute walk), and a short walk to Wall Street, Federal Hall, and the New York Stock Exchange. Pier 17 with East River views is also a 10-minute walk away.
• Transportation: The hotel is a five-minute walk from multiple subway lines, including the Fulton Street subway stop which offers access to 11 train lines, making it easy to reach other parts of the city. While it's a 15-minute subway ride to Times Square, the location is ideal for those focused on Lower Manhattan.

7. Value & Pricing

The Beekman is a luxury hotel, and its pricing reflects that.

• Price Range: Room rates can vary significantly, with standard rooms ranging from approximately $148 to over $1,000 per night, depending on the season and booking method. Off-season prices might be around $450-$582 per night, while summer prices can go well over $750 to $1,000.
• Points Value: As a Category 6 property in the World of Hyatt program, it can be a good value for Hyatt points, costing between 21,000 and 29,000 points per night for a standard room. Booking with points can also waive resort fees and provide benefits like free valet parking.
• Perceived Value: Many guests feel they receive "five-star treatment" and get their money's worth, especially when considering the unique experience and amenities. Booking through programs like American Express Fine Hotels + Resorts can offer additional benefits like room upgrades, free breakfast, and dining credits, enhancing the value.

8. Common Complaints

While largely positive, some recurring issues and criticisms have been noted:

• Noise: Some rooms, particularly those on lower floors or facing the street, can experience noise from nearby construction or the vibrant Bar Room area. Soundproofing in windows has been cited as an issue.
• Lack of Natural Light/Views: Due to the historic building's design, some rooms, especially those facing inner courtyards, may have limited natural light and no view. While some find this acceptable given the vintage vibe, others find it "depressing."
• Dining Service Inconsistencies: While the food quality is generally high, some guests have experienced slow service during breakfast or found certain menu items (like oatmeal) to be underwhelming for the price.
• Room Design Preferences: A few guests found the "dilapidated Victorian aesthetic" or sparse furnishing of some rooms to be "cold" or not to their modern, minimalist taste.
• No Full Spa: The hotel does not have a full spa on-site, though in-room spa services can be arranged.

Sources

1. upgradedpoints.com
2. michelin.com
3. thebeekman.com
4. offthebeatenpoints.com
5. frequentmiler.com
6. thepointsguy.com
7. theemptynestexplorers.com
8. reddit.com
9. oyster.com
10. timeout.com
11. thepointsguy.com
12. reddit.com
13. thebeekman.com
14. onemileatatime.com
15. youtube.com
16. momondo.com
17. kayak.com
18. expedia.com