Hutton Brickyards

Hutton Brickyards, a Michelin Key Selected property nestled in the Catskills & Hudson Valley, offers a distinctive luxury retreat experience on a sprawling 100-acre riverfront estate. Praised for its unique blend of industrial heritage and modern design, the property consistently garners positive guest feedback.

1. Overall Rating & Sentiment

Hutton Brickyards generally receives excellent to very good ratings, often scoring around 8.8 to 9.0 out of 10 on various platforms. Guests frequently describe it as a "beautiful property," "unique," and a "luxurious retreat." It has been affectionately called "summer camp for adults" by Travel & Leisure and noted for "setting a new standard for quirky luxury" by Frommer's. The overall sentiment is highly positive, emphasizing a serene escape and a deep connection to nature.

2. Key Highlights

Guests are particularly drawn to several standout features:

• Location & Design: The hotel boasts a picturesque 100-acre riverfront setting on the Hudson, showcasing a compelling mix of modern architecture and preserved industrial elements from its past as a brick-making facility. The stunning views of the Hudson River are a recurring highlight.
• Amenities: Hutton Brickyards offers an array of amenities designed for relaxation and activity, including free WiFi, room service, complimentary bicycle rentals, cozy fire pits, and beautifully maintained gardens. Unique offerings include spa cabins and waterfront barrel saunas. The property also provides opportunities for outdoor activities like yoga, cycling, and hiking.
• Uniqueness: The property's distinctive "quirky luxury" and "unique aesthetic style" are frequently celebrated, providing a luxurious yet immersive natural experience.

3. Room Quality

Hutton Brickyards offers a variety of accommodations, including riverfront cabins, Victorian-style rooms in the historic Edgewood Mansion, and forest queen cabins.

• Design & Comfort: Rooms are thoughtfully designed to maximize privacy and river views, often featuring clean lines softened by Shaker-inspired furnishings, rich hardwood floors, and ceilings. The Edgewood Mansion rooms blend original 19th-century details with contemporary touches. Cabins are described as "cozy, romantic, clean, and comfortable," each typically equipped with a deck or patio. Some riverfront cabins feature an entire glass end, offering uninterrupted views of the Hudson.
• In-Room Amenities: Standard room amenities include laptop-friendly workspaces, bathrobes, free WiFi, safes, coffee/tea makers, and complimentary toiletries. Notably, some cabins omit televisions, which some guests appreciate for fostering connection with partners or nature.

4. Dining Experience

The primary on-site dining establishment is the River Pavilion, an open-air restaurant featuring wood-fired cooking for lunch and dinner.

• Cuisine: The River Pavilion is known for its delicious seafood, sublime lamb chops, roasted oysters with citrus butter, and fig and brie wood-fired pizzas. Guests generally find the restaurant's offerings delicious with a good variety.
• Breakfast: Breakfast can be conveniently ordered via an in-cabin tablet and delivered directly to the room. However, some guests have expressed disappointment with the breakfast quality relative to the price.
• Other Options: The Larder offers lighter fare and picnic supplies. A roving afternoon cocktail cart is also available to cabins, adding a unique touch to the guest experience. There is also mention of the Edgewood Restaurant + Bar.

5. Service & Staff

Guest feedback on service and staff is largely positive, with many describing the team as "attentive," "helpful," "polite," and "welcoming." Multilingual staff are available to assist guests. For event planning, particularly weddings, staff like coordinators have been commended for their accessibility and responsiveness.

However, some areas for improvement have been noted. A few guests have reported issues with unclear check-in instructions and difficulty reaching staff by phone, leading to delays and frustration. Employee reviews also suggest challenges with being overworked and a lack of clear communication between various departments, which could impact guest service.

6. Location & Accessibility

Hutton Brickyards is strategically located on the Hudson River in Kingston, New York, approximately 90 miles north of Manhattan.

• Local Attractions: The property offers good access to local points of interest, including Kingston Point Beach (an 8-minute walk), Kingston Point Dog Park (a 9-minute walk), the Trolley Museum of New York (a 19-minute walk), and the Hudson River Maritime Museum (a 2-minute drive). Guests appreciate the option to explore nearby Kingston, which offers shops and restaurants.
• Transport: The hotel is near a train station, and complimentary parking is available for one vehicle per room. Free bicycle rentals are also provided for exploring the grounds and surrounding trails.
• Property Accessibility: The property is single-level with a well-lit path to the entrance, but does not have an elevator. One guest noted that the hotel area is "far from everything," implying that personal transportation or reliance on hotel services is advisable.

7. Value & Pricing

As of January 29, 2026, a 1-night stay for two adults starts from approximately $304.87, excluding taxes and fees. Guests should also factor in a $30 destination fee per accommodation per night and a $200 deposit per stay.

While many find the experience worth the cost, some guests feel that for the price point, certain aspects like breakfast quality and in-room amenities (e.g., a fully stocked minibar) could be improved. For large events like weddings, Hutton Brickyards provides the venue, accommodations, and beverage services, but requires external vendors for catering, staffing, and rentals (tables, chairs, linens, etc.). This "canvas" approach can lead to higher overall costs than initially anticipated, highlighting the importance of thorough budget planning and often necessitating a wedding planner.

8. Common Complaints

While generally highly rated, some recurring criticisms include:

• Check-in Experience: A lack of clear check-in instructions and difficulty reaching staff via phone for assistance has been reported, causing initial frustration for some guests.
• Breakfast Quality: Several guests have found the breakfast to be "disappointing" in relation to the overall cost of the stay.
• Limited In-Room Amenities: The absence of a full minibar with snacks and drinks has been a point of contention for some, especially given the hotel's somewhat secluded location.
• Restaurant Operating Hours: As of a June 2024 review, the on-site restaurant, River Pavilion, is not open for dinner from Sunday to Wednesday.
• Event Planning Complexity: For weddings and large events, the venue's model (providing venue, accommodation, and beverages, but requiring outside vendors for most other services) can be complex and expensive, often requiring a dedicated event planner. There have been some isolated reports of uncooperative management in past wedding reviews, though this appears to be less common in recent feedback.

Sources

1. expedia.com
2. hotels.com
3. weddingwire.com
4. theknot.com
5. booking.com
6. huttonbrickyards.com
7. tablethotels.com
8. timesunion.com
9. huttonbrickyards.com
10. townandcountrymag.com
11. huttonbrickyards.com
12. indeed.com
13. reddit.com