Hotel St. Paul

Hotel St. Paul in Montreal, Canada, a Michelin Key Selected property, offers a distinctive stay within a beautifully restored Beaux-Arts building in the heart of Old Montreal. It is recognized as Canada's first Design Hotel, boasting an elegant and contemporary aesthetic.

1. Overall Rating & Sentiment

The general consensus for Hotel St. Paul leans positive, with ratings often falling into the "Very Good" to "Excellent" range (e.g., 8.1-8.4 out of 10). Guests frequently appreciate its prime location, striking design, and comfortable accommodations. However, there are recurring concerns regarding inconsistent service quality, occasional issues with room cleanliness, and some guests finding room sizes to be smaller than expected for a four-star establishment. Dissatisfaction with breakfast options and pricing also appears in guest feedback.

2. Key Highlights

Guests consistently praise the hotel's exceptional location, placing it within easy walking distance of Old Montreal's main attractions and the Old Port. The hotel's unique and innovative design, transforming a historic landmark into a modern, minimalist space, is a significant draw. The lobby features stylish contemporary furnishings and a notable fireplace made of translucent alabaster. Comfortable beds and amenities are also frequently highlighted. The hotel has received numerous national and international awards, including being a TripAdvisor Traveler's Choice winner in 2020, placing it in the top 10% of hotels worldwide.

3. Room Quality

Hotel St. Paul's rooms are described as clean, stylish, modern, and comfortable. They feature high ceilings and large windows that offer panoramic views of the old quarter. The design incorporates traditional materials like polished hardwoods, raw metal, and exposed stone, combined with clean, crisp modernist lines. Many guests laud the comfort and quietness of the beds, ensuring a good night's sleep. Bathrooms are often noted for their stylish fittings and square marble sinks, resembling "little museums". In-room amenities include a coffee machine, mini-bar, desk, safety deposit box, and a flat-screen TV. Some suites are particularly spacious, such as the Junior Suites and Deluxe King Suites. Blackout drapes and plush bathrobes contribute to the comfort.

4. Dining Experience

The hotel offers a buffet breakfast in an art-filled breakfast lounge, available daily with a selection of pastries, continental options, cold cuts, fresh fruits, and hot beverages. Children under 12 can eat for free with paying adults. However, complimentary breakfast is not generally offered, and some guests have found the cost to be high (e.g., $35 for the buffet, with an additional $7 for coffee). The hotel features a newly opened Japanese-inspired restaurant named Yubari, serving refined Asian flavors for lunch and dinner. Room service is also available, including breakfast in bed and Yubari specialties.

5. Service & Staff

Feedback on service and staff is varied. Many guests have praised the staff for being welcoming, helpful, friendly, and providing excellent service. However, other reviews indicate concerns regarding the overall service quality, with some experiences citing staff who seemed unfamiliar with hotel offerings or lacked a consistently warm demeanor.

6. Location & Accessibility

The Hotel St. Paul's location is consistently highlighted as a major advantage. It is situated in the heart of Old Montreal on McGill Street, offering easy access to prominent attractions such as the Old Port, the Notre-Dame Basilica, the World Trade Center, and the shops on St. Catherine Street. Guests appreciate the ability to explore the historic area on foot. Furthermore, a nearby underground metro station provides convenient access to other parts of the city. The hotel is also accessible via bus from the airport.

7. Value & Pricing

Value and pricing receive mixed opinions. While the hotel's unique design and excellent location are often seen as justifying the cost for some, other guests feel that the overall experience, particularly regarding service and breakfast pricing, does not always align with the price point of a four-star property. Average weeknight prices have been observed around C$369, with weekend nights averaging C$252, though rates can fluctuate significantly depending on the season, with August being the most expensive and February or March typically being the cheapest.

8. Common Complaints

Several recurring issues and criticisms have been noted by guests. These include inconsistent service quality, occasional issues with room cleanliness, and rooms being smaller than anticipated for a hotel of its star rating. Specific complaints mention maintenance issues such as slow-draining bathtubs, poor bathroom ventilation causing shower curtains to blow inward, faulty shower taps, empty conditioner bottles, rusted irons, and non-functional thermostats. The breakfast offering is also a point of contention, with some guests finding it to be unsatisfactory or overpriced, especially since coffee might not be included in the buffet price. Some reviews also noted a lack of personalized recognition for loyalty program members.

Sources

1. marriott.com
2. hotelstpaul.com
3. booking.com
4. kayak.com
5. priceline.com
6. kayak.com
7. princeoftravel.com
8. reddit.com
9. tablethotels.com
10. michelin.com
11. hotelstpaul.com
12. hotels.com
13. hotelstpaul.com
14. marriott.com
15. hotelstpaul.com
16. designhotels.com
17. expedia.ca