Waldorf Astoria New York

The Waldorf Astoria New York, a legendary Art Deco icon, has been reborn following an extensive eight-year, $2 billion renovation, officially reopening its doors in July 2025. The transformation significantly reduced the number of hotel rooms from 1,400 to 375, converting the upper stories into luxury residences, allowing for more spacious guest accommodations and enhanced focus on service. This meticulous restoration has cemented its status as a Michelin Key Selected property, offering a blend of historic grandeur and modern luxury.

1. Overall Rating & Sentiment

The general consensus post-renovation is overwhelmingly positive. Guests describe the hotel as "grander than ever," oozing glamour and history while feeling fresh and modern. It's celebrated as a "reborn" legend that has regained its place at the pinnacle of luxury hospitality, with many calling it a "sumptuous experience" and a definitive New York stay. The magic of New York's Gilded Age is said to be revived for a new generation, with world-class service to match.

2. Key Highlights

Guests consistently praise the Waldorf Astoria's stunning Art Deco design and architecture, meticulously restored public spaces, and sophisticated ambiance. The dramatically reimagined public areas, including the soaring Park Avenue lobby with its mosaic floors, murals, and the iconic 1893 World's Fair clock, are frequently highlighted. The spacious, redesigned rooms, the world-class Guerlain Wellness Spa (which opened in October 2025), and the exceptional, enthusiastic staff are also major drawcards. The hotel's historical significance and ability to flawlessly merge its storied past with contemporary luxury are also key highlights.

3. Room Quality

The redesigned rooms and suites are noted for being significantly more spacious, with many layouts starting at a sprawling 570 square feet, often double the original room sizes. They are described as exuding refined luxury, feeling like small luxury apartments rather than typical hotel rooms. The design by Pierre-Yves Rochon incorporates soft Art Deco-inspired details with a light, muted palette of dove, taupe, and white, featuring subtle hints of chocolate and pistachio. Rooms boast up-to-date, high-end amenities, automated drapery, ultra-comfortable beds, and spa-like bathrooms with deep soaking tubs, separate showers, and oversized marble vanities. Guests have noted the rooms are wonderfully quiet, even those overlooking Park Avenue, thanks to double-glazed windows. Junior Suites, for instance, include a small foyer, living area, and a spa-worthy bathroom.

4. Dining Experience

The Waldorf Astoria New York features three distinctive dining venues: Lex Yard, Peacock Alley, and Yoshoku.

• Lex Yard: An American brasserie led by chef Michael Anthony, focusing on seasonal, locally sourced ingredients. It's open for breakfast, lunch, and dinner, offering dishes like the Waldorf salad, Lex Burger, roast chicken, and red velvet soufflé tart. Food here is generally described as wonderful and delicious, though breakfast can be pricey.
• Peacock Alley: The historic lobby lounge and bar, known for refined cuisine and cocktails. It offers elevated bar food such as housemade pigs in a blanket, mini crab cakes, caviar service, and a loaded lobster roll. It's a popular spot for lounging, though service can sometimes be slow.
• Yoshoku: An intimate Japanese restaurant offering kaiseki-inspired cuisine, with both tasting and à la carte menus featuring selections of maki, nigiri, foie gras-topped venison, and Wagyu striploin. The hotel is also historically significant for popularizing dishes like Eggs Benedict, red velvet cake, and the Waldorf salad, which can still be found on the menus.

5. Service & Staff

The service at the Waldorf Astoria New York post-renovation is frequently highlighted as exceptional. Guests describe the staff as "amazing," "outstanding across various departments," "friendly, personable, and wanting to go beyond" to make the stay special. From valet and doormen to front desk, restaurant staff, and housekeeping, every employee interaction is reported to be aimed at pleasing the guest, delivering attentive yet discreet service. One review noted the staff's enthusiasm to welcome guests back, leading to an experience where "the magic... feels revived... with world-class service to match".

6. Location & Accessibility

The Waldorf Astoria New York occupies an entire city block in Midtown East, between Park and Lexington Avenues. Its prime location offers excellent accessibility, being within walking distance of major attractions such as Grand Central Terminal, 5th Avenue, Rockefeller Center, and several subway lines (51st St. Station and Lexington Av.-53 St. Station are just a few minutes away). The redesigned property is also noted for being more accessible than ever, with public and in-room features to assist people with various needs, and all public spaces and guest room floors accessible via elevator.

7. Value & Pricing

Staying at the Waldorf Astoria New York is considered a significant splurge, with junior suites starting at approximately $1,200 to $1,500 per night. While it is a high price point, many guests feel the experience is worth the cost, particularly for its historical grandeur, world-class amenities, and impeccable service. For those able to book using points or free night certificates, it can be an even more appealing option. The hotel's transformation and the resulting luxurious experience are seen as justifying the premium pricing.

8. Common Complaints

Given the recent and extensive renovation, most post-reopening feedback is overwhelmingly positive, significantly addressing past criticisms regarding outdated decor and smaller rooms. However, some minor points have been noted:

• High Costs: The dining and spa services are acknowledged as being very pricey. For instance, a breakfast at Lex Yard could cost over $60, and spa treatments can be hundreds of dollars.
• Service Inconsistencies: While overall service is lauded, one review mentioned that service "felt less than five-star at moments". Another specifically noted that service at Peacock Alley can be a bit slow.
• Room Views: One guest in a junior suite noted a lack of a view, looking into an office building across the street, which was described as "a little depressing".

Overall, the Waldorf Astoria New York has successfully re-established itself as a paragon of luxury, blending its iconic Art Deco heritage with contemporary comfort and exceptional service.

Sources

1. wikipedia.org
2. travelweekly.com
3. thepointsguy.com
4. afar.com
5. theluxurytravelatlas.com
6. michelin.com
7. oyster.com
8. hotels.com
9. waldorfastorianewyork.com
10. youtube.com
11. youtube.com
12. youtube.com
13. reddit.com
14. youtube.com
15. joshtrips.com
16. wallpaper.com
17. headforpoints.com
18. booking.com
19. hilton.com
20. resy.com
21. expedia.com
22. boardingarea.com
23. fodors.com