The Shoals Suites & Slips

The Shoals Suites & Slips, a Michelin Key Selected property on North Fork Long Island, offers a distinctive "boatel" experience that consistently garners positive guest feedback for its chic design, prime waterfront location, and attentive service.

1. Overall Rating & Sentiment

The general consensus for The Shoals Suites & Slips is overwhelmingly positive, with guests frequently rating their stays as "Exceptional" or "Wonderful." Across various platforms, average scores range from 9.2 to 9.4 out of 10. Guests highlight the property's modern, clean, and spacious accommodations, along with its peaceful and picturesque setting.

2. Key Highlights

Guests consistently praise several aspects of The Shoals. The design, spearheaded by Danish architect Thomas Juul-Hansen, is frequently mentioned, blending "chic Scandi spareness with seafaring features" and a "European modernist influence." The property's location directly on the waterfront, overlooking Peconic Bay and with views of Shelter Island, is a major draw, offering stunning marina views and easy access to both land and sea activities. The amenities are also a highlight, including private boat slips for each of its 20 suites, complimentary bicycle rentals, and a garden terrace with a fire pit. Many guests appreciate the well-stocked kitchenettes in the rooms.

3. Room Quality

The rooms at The Shoals are described as "absolutely beautiful," "updated, well-decorated and spacious." They offer an "apartment-style living" experience with custom designs by Thomas Juul-Hansen, aiming to create a sense of calm and retreat. Each of the 20 air-conditioned suites features individual decor, separate sitting areas, and opens to a furnished balcony or patio. Comfort is paramount, with incredibly comfortable beds, premium bedding, and Frette sheets and towels often singled out for praise, contributing to a great night's sleep. In-room amenities include espresso makers, bathrobes, mini-fridges, free bottled water, and Malin + Goetz toiletries. Kitchenettes are a common feature, though some guests noted the absence of a freezer in some.

4. Dining Experience

The dining experience at The Shoals is unique and casual. The hotel's primary restaurant offering is a food truck parked on the grounds, which is notably manned by a Michelin-starred chef from North Fork Table & Inn. This "Ferrari of 'meals on wheels'" serves items like burgers and lobster rolls. On Wednesday evenings, the Little Ram Oyster Co. takes over, offering an oyster-focused experience. For breakfast, an array of freshly baked pastries are served in the lounge, with a continental breakfast generally well-received by guests. There's also a bar/lounge and a coffee shop/cafe on-site. While there's no traditional room service, all suites are equipped with kitchens for in-room meals. Nearby, guests can explore other dining options like North Fork Table & Inn and Southold Social.

5. Service & Staff

The service and staff at The Shoals consistently receive high praise. Guests frequently mention the "friendly staff," "immensely kind" individuals, and helpful front desk personnel who offer tips for local activities. The hospitality is often described as going "above and beyond" to ensure a memorable stay. The overall staff performance rating is strong, indicating attentive and accommodating service.

6. Location & Accessibility

The Shoals Suites & Slips is ideally situated in Southold on Long Island's North Fork, a quieter and more authentically rural destination compared to the Hamptons. Its waterfront position provides stunning views of Peconic Bay and Shelter Island. The location is excellent for exploring the North Fork, known for its vineyards, farmstands, and locavore dining. Attractions like The Old Field Vineyards are minutes away. The hotel offers free use of bicycles and beach passes, encouraging guests to explore the surrounding area. For those arriving by water, each suite comes with an assigned boat slip. While Southold itself is a small town, it offers fine restaurants, and the North Fork wineries are easily accessible further west. International airports like LaGuardia and JFK are approximately a two-hour drive away, with Long Island MacArthur Airport being a closer option for domestic travel.

7. Value & Pricing

While specific price ranges can fluctuate, Kayak lists rooms starting from approximately $159 for a King room, with standard and double rooms ranging from $293 to $296. Google Hotels also shows rates starting from $145 for various suites. It's important to note that prices can vary by season, with January and May often presenting the cheapest deals. Some guests have felt that the value for the price could be improved, particularly in relation to perceived noise levels. A mandatory resort fee of $25.00 per accommodation, per night (during April 1 - November 30) includes beach access, beach towels, concierge service, housekeeping, in-room bottled water, in-room coffee, and parking.

8. Common Complaints

Despite the generally high praise, a few recurring issues have been noted by guests. The most common complaint centers around noise levels. Some guests have reported thin walls, leading to audible conversations from adjacent rooms and noise from upstairs neighbors. One specific instance mentioned a persistent machine-like noise outside a ground-floor suite that disrupted sleep. Another minor point of contention for some has been the size of certain rooms, with some finding bedrooms too small to comfortably open suitcases, requiring them to use the living room instead. Additionally, a few isolated reports mentioned cleanliness concerns in specific rooms or issues with debit card charges.

Sources

1. kayak.com
2. booking.com
3. hotels.com
4. booking.com
5. mrandmrssmith.com
6. michelin.com
7. expedia.com
8. wanderlog.com
9. theshoalsnorthfork.com
10. booking.com
11. theshoalsnorthfork.com
12. agoda.com
13. google.com.jm
14. google.com.ng