The Old Manse of Blair

The Old Manse of Blair, a Michelin Key Selected property nestled in Blair Atholl, United Kingdom, consistently receives glowing reviews for its luxurious experience, exceptional service, and stunning Highland setting. Guests frequently describe it as a truly unforgettable stay, blending historic charm with modern comforts and exquisite dining.

1. Overall Rating & Sentiment

The general consensus for The Old Manse of Blair is overwhelmingly positive, with an average rating often scoring around 9.1 out of 10, or "Superb" based on numerous reviews. Guests express sentiments ranging from "wonderful place" and "unforgettable" to a "5-star luxury experience". The hotel is praised as a "hidden gem in the Highlands" and a "perfect romantic getaway".

2. Key Highlights

Guests consistently highlight several aspects that make their stay exceptional:

• Service & Staff: The staff are frequently described as "extraordinary," "super friendly," "helpful," and "impeccable," going "above and beyond" to ensure comfort and a welcoming atmosphere. Many appreciate the genuine hospitality and the feeling of being at home.
• Location & Surroundings: The "gorgeous location" within the Cairngorms National Park, set on a 10-acre private estate with meticulously landscaped grounds and a walled garden, is a major draw. The presence of two resident Highland cows, James and John, is a unique and much-loved amenity, particularly for families.
• Dining Experience: The Michelin-selected restaurant is a significant highlight, offering a "phenomenal" and "extraordinary" culinary journey.
• Design & Ambiance: The hotel's historic charm, Georgian style, and recent extensive refurbishment, combining traditional elegance with modern luxury, are frequently lauded. Guests appreciate the peaceful, cosy, and opulent atmosphere.

3. Room Quality

The rooms at The Old Manse of Blair are consistently described as "clean and comfortable," "very comfortable," and "luxurious". They feature private bathrooms, garden views, flat-screen TVs, and work desks. The decor is often noted for its contemporary flair, with bold colours, large mirrors, and interesting artwork, creating a chic ambiance. Specific mentions include "stunning bathrooms" and, in suites like the Georgian, spacious layouts with open fires and doors leading directly to the grounds. Some rooms, particularly newer guest cabins, offer a separate, quiet experience.

4. Dining Experience

Dining at The Old Manse of Blair's Orangery Restaurant is a "gastronomic adventure," recognized in the Michelin Guide for its "Scottish to the core" approach. Executive Head Chef Scott Davies, a MasterChef: The Professionals finalist, focuses on meticulously sourced local, seasonal ingredients, including Skye langoustine, Perthshire mallard, and venison. Dishes are described as "showstopping" and "exquisite."

Breakfast is also highly praised, including a full Scottish breakfast, Scotch pancakes, and Perthshire berries. The restaurant is family-friendly, offering dedicated children's menus. Guests also enjoy pre-dinner aperitifs or nightcaps in the serene drawing-room by the fire, often accompanied by a baby grand piano.

5. Service & Staff

The service at The Old Manse of Blair is consistently rated as "impeccable" and a significant reason for guest satisfaction. Staff members are described as "professional and friendly," "attentive and efficient without being intrusive." They are commended for making guests feel "extremely comfortable" and "at home". The Gaelic-speaking MacDonald family, who own and operate the hotel, are noted for their warm Hebridean hospitality.

6. Location & Accessibility

The Old Manse of Blair boasts an "excellent location" in Blair Atholl, within the Cairngorms National Park. It is conveniently situated between the historic Blair Castle and the renowned House of Bruar. The property is set within 10 acres of grounds, offering a tranquil and beautiful setting for walks. It is approximately 15 minutes by car from Pitlochry and accessible via the A9 and Blair Atholl railway station. The hotel is committed to inclusivity and provides an accessibility statement for guests with specific needs.

7. Value & Pricing

While specific price ranges vary, The Old Manse of Blair is considered a luxury experience. Some reviews indicate an average price of around $375 per room, suggesting it offers "exceptional value for money" compared to other hotels in Blair Atholl. However, a few guests have noted that rooms, particularly suites, might be "slightly overpriced". The quality of the food and overall experience often justifies the cost for many visitors.

8. Common Complaints

While overwhelmingly positive, a few minor recurring issues have been mentioned:

• Room Temperature: On exceptionally hot days, some guests found rooms to be "a little hot," though fans were provided.
• Noise: A few instances of noise between rooms in the walled garden bedrooms have been reported, suggesting a potential for improved soundproofing.
• Restaurant Ambiance/Attentiveness (Minor): One guest suggested that restaurant lighting could be dimmer for a more elegant vibe and that staff could be slightly more attentive in offering drinks upon arrival.
• Limited Storage: One reviewer noted a lack of space for wet clothes when entering a room from outside.

Sources

1. booking.com
2. booking.com
3. theoldmanseofblair.com
4. theoldmanseofblair.com
5. booking.com
6. squaremeal.co.uk
7. michelin.com
8. thehotelguru.com
9. theoldmanseofblair.com
10. scots2travel.com
11. theoldmanseofblair.com
12. thefork.co.uk
13. agoda.com