The Lodge at St. Edward Park

The Lodge at St. Edward Park: A Serene Escape with Historic Charm and Michelin Recognition

The Lodge at St. Edward Park, a Michelin One-Key property in Kenmore, United States, has garnered a strong reputation as a unique luxury boutique hotel. Nestled within a sprawling 326-acre state park, guests consistently praise its ability to offer a tranquil, nature-infused retreat that feels miles away from the city, yet remains conveniently accessible to the greater Seattle metropolitan area.

Overall Rating & Sentiment

The general consensus for The Lodge at St. Edward Park is overwhelmingly positive, with guest review scores typically ranging from 8.8 to 9.0 out of 10. It is frequently described as "exceptional" and a "hidden treasure" for those seeking a luxurious and peaceful getaway. The hotel has also been recognized with a Condé Nast Traveler Readers' Choice honor.

Key Highlights

Guests consistently laud the hotel's historic charm and thoughtful design, as the former seminary building has been meticulously restored and transformed into a luxury destination. The beautiful and expansive grounds of St. Edward State Park are a major draw, offering a rustic and peaceful atmosphere with abundant hiking and biking trails, including an easy hike down to Lake Washington. The attentive and friendly staff are also frequently highlighted for providing exceptional service. Furthermore, amenities like the on-site spa (Vita Nova Spa) and diverse dining options contribute significantly to the guest experience.

Room Quality

The 84 guest rooms and suites at The Lodge at St. Edward Park are celebrated for their comfort, elegance, and design, which thoughtfully blends the building's historic character with modern luxury. Each room is notably spacious, often combining two of the original seminary students' bedrooms, and features restored windows that frame pastoral views of the park's greenery. Decorations include murals based on original architectural blueprints and nature photographs. Rooms are equipped with 4-star comforts such as air-conditioning, private bathrooms with natural stone accents and glass showers, work desks, Smart TVs, Nespresso coffee machines, free toiletries (including Grown Alchemist products), and a custom pillow menu. While generally praised, one guest did note that the bed was "way too soft," causing a backache, and suggested a firmer mattress would improve the experience. Another review mentioned some small rooms, especially when booked through certain reward programs, where there was barely enough space for luggage.

Dining Experience

The Lodge at St. Edward Park offers a recognized dining experience with a focus on Pacific Northwest cuisine and seasonal, local ingredients.

• Cedar + Elm: This signature restaurant serves seasonal Pacific Northwest fare in a "sunny and grand double-height dining room" and offers brunch, lunch, and dinner. Executive Chef Luke Kolpin, known for appearing on Bravo's Top Chef, leads the culinary team. Guests have praised the delicious food, including dishes like crisp, raw oysters and black garlic braised short ribs.
• Father Mulligan's Heritage Bar: This offers a more casual atmosphere for light bites, craft beer, and cocktails, often described as a convenient and enjoyable spot.
• The Tonsorium Bar: Located in the seminary's old barbershop, this subterranean bar is known for its inventive mixology.
• Breakfast: An à la carte breakfast with warm dishes is served, which guests have described as delicious.
• Other options: Room service is available, and high tea is also offered. There is also a coffee shop/cafe on site. Some guests noted a perceived lack of room service availability or restaurant accommodation for larger parties at times, suggesting possible understaffing issues.

Service & Staff

The service and staff at The Lodge at St. Edward Park consistently receive high praise. Guests frequently describe the staff as "exceptional," "friendly," "attentive," "kind," "happy," and "professional." From valet service to check-out, the hospitality is often highlighted as a standout feature. The events staff, in particular, has been commended for being professional and accommodating for weddings. However, some guest feedback mentioned isolated service issues, such as check-in delays, room availability problems, and one instance of a "very rude bartender."

Location & Accessibility

The Lodge at St. Edward Park boasts a prime and unique location within the 326-acre Saint Edward State Park in Kenmore, Washington. This setting offers a serene, lakeside forest environment with miles of hiking and biking trails, providing a secluded feel despite being just 15 miles from Seattle. It's approximately a 30-minute drive from Seattle, Bellevue, or Everett.

The hotel provides complimentary valet parking and offers a local shuttle service within a 10-mile radius, based on availability. The front entrance of the hotel is wheelchair accessible with a ramp and a lift to the lobby level, and accessible routes are available to common areas like restaurants and fitness facilities.

Value & Pricing

While The Lodge at St. Edward Park is considered a luxury property, guest opinions on its value for money can vary. Booking.com scores "Value for money" at 7.7. Weekend rates for double occupancy can start at a "splurge-level" of $400 per night, plus taxes and a $10 state park fee. Mid-week stays may be found for under $300, and last-minute deals can offer up to 20% off Sunday-Thursday stays. Some guests have expressed disappointment regarding the value for the price paid, particularly when encountering service issues or smaller rooms through certain booking methods. However, others feel the unique experience, amenities, and beautiful setting justify the cost, noting that the hotel offers free WiFi, free valet parking, in-room Nespresso, snacks and drinks in the library, lawn games, and bike rentals as part of a daily resort fee.

Common Complaints

While largely positive, recurring criticisms include:

• Service Issues: Some guests have reported check-in delays, issues with room availability, and occasional understaffing, which impacted the overall luxury experience they expected for the price. Room service was also reportedly unavailable to some guests despite being advertised.
• Bed Firmness: At least one guest found the bed "way too soft," leading to discomfort.
• Room Size: While generally spacious, some guests who booked through specific rewards programs mentioned receiving "tiniest rooms" with insufficient space for luggage.
• Food Quality/Consistency: While the dining is generally praised, some older reviews noted the food quality could be lacking.

Sources

1. booking.com
2. tablethotels.com
3. michelin.com
4. stashrewards.com
5. foreverlostintravel.com
6. visitseattle.org
7. costcotravel.com
8. thelodgeatstedward.com
9. youtube.com
10. kayak.com
11. cvent.com
12. slh.com
13. parentmap.com
14. kenmoreair.com
15. hotels.com
16. expedia.com
17. travelocity.com
18. theknot.com
19. hilton.com
20. thelodgeatstedward.com