Poggio Piglia

Poggio Piglia, a Michelin Key Selected property nestled in the picturesque Tuscan countryside near Chiusi, offers guests a sophisticated blend of old-world charm and modern elegance. This seasonal hotel, open from late March to the end of October, is frequently praised for its stunning location, exceptional service, and tranquil atmosphere.

1. Overall Rating & Sentiment

The general consensus for Poggio Piglia is overwhelmingly positive, with guests consistently rating it as "Exceptional." Across various platforms, it boasts high scores for cleanliness (9.8), location (9.7), facilities (9.6), comfort (9.7), and most notably, staff (9.9). The sentiment is one of relaxation, warmth, and luxury without pretentiousness, often described as a "timeless paradise."

2. Key Highlights

Guests consistently laud Poggio Piglia for several standout features:

• Location & Views: Its strategic hilltop position, surrounded by olive groves and vineyards, offers sweeping panoramic views of the famous Tuscan countryside. This makes it an ideal, peaceful retreat.
• Service & Staff: The "truly lovely hospitality" and "amazing" staff, particularly mentioning Sergio and Katia, are frequently highlighted. Guests appreciate their attentiveness, helpfulness with bookings and tours, and genuine warmth.
• Design & Ambiance: The hotel's design, which thoughtfully blends a traditional stone country house silhouette with crisp, minimalist interiors, artwork, and sculptural furniture, is a major draw. The sparkling infinity pool set in herb-scented gardens with spectacular views is also a guest favorite.
• Amenities: The onsite production of ruby-hued Sangiovese wine and olive oil, available to guests, adds to the authentic Tuscan experience.

3. Room Quality

The rooms at Poggio Piglia are described as spacious, comfortable, and beautifully designed. They feature wood-beamed ceilings, natural stone walls, and hardwood or parquet flooring, blending rustic elements with modern sophistication. Many rooms include romantic fireplaces and pristine glass-encased showers in large, well-appointed bathrooms. Select Comfort mattresses contribute to exceptional sleep quality, and in-room amenities typically include flat-screen TVs, minibars, and Be One bath products. The Independent Villa, set apart and surrounded by olive trees, is particularly noted for its romantic, private feel and panoramic views.

4. Dining Experience

The dining experience at Poggio Piglia is highly praised. Breakfast is typically a "great" buffet that often includes a menu à la carte with options like fresh omelettes, charcuterie, cheese, and salads. The hotel's restaurant, featuring a contemporary chef like Jacopo Dionisi or Salvatore, offers "delightful" and "exquisite" Italian dishes, balancing traditional and playful elements, such as tagliata of Chianina beef or pork fillet with raspberries and truffles. The restaurant also pairs its classic pastas and meats with the hotel's own Sangiovese wine and olive oil. Guests often dine on the terrace to enjoy the views.

5. Service & Staff

The service and staff at Poggio Piglia are consistently highlighted as outstanding. Guests frequently describe the team as "friendly," "warm," "welcoming," "attentive," and "professional." They are noted for going "above and beyond" to ensure comfort, assisting with restaurant and wine tour bookings, and making guests feel like "staying with a local family." Specific individuals like Sergio, the manager, and Katia and Roberta are often mentioned for their exceptional helpfulness.

6. Location & Accessibility

Poggio Piglia is strategically located in the hamlet of Macciano, Chiusi, in the Tuscan countryside, southeast of Siena on the road to Rome. This position provides a "deliciously remote and peaceful" setting, while also offering convenient access for day trips to Siena, Assisi, and even Rome or Florence by car. It's also well-situated for exploring verdant vineyards, hilltop towns, and rustic trattorias. The property is 3.2 miles from the center of Chiusi and has convenient access to the A1 highway, being 2.5 miles from the Umbrian border and a 10-minute drive from Chianciano Terme. A car is recommended for exploring the surrounding area.

7. Value & Pricing

While specific price ranges vary depending on dates and room types, guests generally consider Poggio Piglia to be worth the cost, with a "value for money" rating of 9.1. Reviews indicate that expectations were "more than exceeded, even for the price range." Standard double rooms can start from approximately $299-$396 per night, with deluxe rooms and villas being higher. The inclusion of a buffet breakfast is a common feature of the rates.

8. Common Complaints

While overwhelmingly positive, a few minor recurring issues or criticisms have been noted:

• Road Access: The last 250 meters of the road leading to the property are gravel. While manageable for most cars, guests with very low-suspension sports cars are advised to drive slowly and carefully.
• Bedding Comfort: Some guests have found the pillows to be "quite hard" and the mattresses, while often Select Comfort, could be more comfortable for a property of this level.
• Restaurant Pricing: One review mentioned the restaurant being "on the expensive side," though the quality of the food was acknowledged. The hotel, in response, highlighted its use of high-quality, costly ingredients.
• No Pool Bar/Consistent Music: A guest suggested more consistent music and a dedicated pool bar would enhance the ambiance.
• Connectivity: While free WiFi is available in communal areas and rooms, one guest noted "hiccups with video calls," advising a backup plan for digital nomads.
• Seasonal Operation: Poggio Piglia is a seasonal hotel, open from late March until the end of October, which may limit booking options for some travelers.

Sources

1. tablethotels.com
2. mrandmrssmith.com
3. michelin.com
4. michelin.com
5. booking.com
6. hotels.com
7. momondo.com
8. booking.com
9. michelin.com
10. booking.com
11. expedia.com
12. booking.com
13. priceline.com