Park Hyatt New York

The Park Hyatt New York, a Michelin Key Selected property, offers a luxurious experience in the heart of Midtown Manhattan, frequently praised for its exquisite design, expansive rooms, and prime location. While the "hard product" – the physical hotel and its amenities – consistently receives high marks, guest feedback on service can be more varied.

1. Overall Rating & Sentiment

The overall sentiment for Park Hyatt New York is generally positive, with guests often describing it as a truly luxurious and special property. Many consider it among the best hotels in New York City. However, this high praise is sometimes tempered by observations regarding service inconsistencies, particularly given its high price point.

2. Key Highlights

Guests consistently highlight several standout features of the Park Hyatt New York:

• Design & Ambiance: The hotel is celebrated for its modern elegance and sophisticated design.
• Amenities: The 25th-floor, 65-foot saltwater lap pool with natural light and city views is a significant draw, along with the oversized hot tub and steam room. The gym also offers city skyline views.
• Location: Its unbeatable Midtown location, just two blocks from Central Park and across from Carnegie Hall, is a major plus for tourism and shopping.
• Room Size: The spaciousness of the rooms, notably large for Manhattan, is a recurring positive.

3. Room Quality

Rooms at the Park Hyatt New York are consistently described as spacious, modern, plush, and luxurious, ranging from 500-625 square feet for standard rooms – approximately double the size of many other standard rooms in the city. Key features include:

• Comfort: Beds are frequently lauded as "best in class" and "unbelievably comfortable," leading to excellent sleep experiences.
• Bathrooms: Bathrooms are typically large and opulent, featuring rainfall showers, marble baths, heated floors, and Le Labo bath amenities. Some suites also boast Japanese toilets. High water pressure is also noted.
• Design & Features: Rooms often include automatic curtains and blinds, Nespresso coffee makers, and twice-daily housekeeping. Views, especially corner or Central Park views, are highly appreciated.

4. Dining Experience

The hotel's dining is primarily centered around "The Living Room" restaurant, which also offers room service.

• Breakfast: Room service breakfast can be delicious, with pancakes and waffles being particularly well-received. However, some guests have noted inconsistencies in room service orders. For non-Globalist guests, breakfast can be very expensive, potentially exceeding $100 for two people.
• Restaurant Quality: The Living Room offers breakfast, lunch, dinner, and cocktails. Dishes like fluffy pancakes and lobster pasta have been highlighted as "genuinely fantastic".
• Unique Offerings: A "picnic in the park" option is available, where the hotel provides a picnic basket and blanket for guests to enjoy in nearby Central Park.

5. Service & Staff

This is an area where guest experiences at Park Hyatt New York can vary significantly.

• Positive Feedback: Many guests praise the staff for being professional, welcoming, attentive, and going "above and beyond". Specific mentions include helpful and warm service in The Living Room and efficient room service delivery.
• Areas for Improvement: Some reviews point to inconsistencies and a lack of the five-star service expected at this price point. Complaints include a lack of warmth and hospitality during check-in, delays in room readiness, underwhelming turndown service (sometimes lacking thoughtful touches like chocolates), and doormen who don't always assist with doors or luggage. Some guests paying with points have perceived a less attentive attitude.

6. Location & Accessibility

The Park Hyatt New York boasts an exceptional location:

• Neighborhood: Situated on 57th Street between Sixth and Seventh avenues in Midtown Manhattan, it's considered a premium spot for sightseeing and luxury shopping.
• Attractions: It's less than a five-minute walk to Central Park, directly across from Carnegie Hall, and about a 10-15 minute walk to the Theater District/Broadway.
• Transport: Subway access is just steps away, making it highly convenient for exploring the city.
• Accessibility: The hotel is noted for its accessibility, offering accessible guest rooms with features like wider doorways, roll-in rainfall showers, and an accessible pool lift.

7. Value & Pricing

The Park Hyatt New York is a high-end luxury property with pricing to match.

• Cash Rates: Standard rooms commonly start at or above $1,000 per night, with some instances of over $2,000 per night.
• Points Redemption: It's a Category 8 World of Hyatt property, with award stays ranging from 35,000 to 45,000 points per night, which many consider an "excellent splurge" and a very good value compared to cash rates.
• Perceived Value: While the physical property and amenities are often deemed worth the cost, some guests feel that the inconsistent service can diminish the overall value for money.

8. Common Complaints

Despite its luxury status, some recurring issues and criticisms are noted:

• Inconsistent Service: This is the most frequent complaint, encompassing issues with check-in warmth, doorman attentiveness, turndown service (lack of details like chocolates), and accuracy of room service orders.
• Lack of Club Lounge: Unlike some other Park Hyatt properties, this location does not have a Club Lounge.
• Breakfast Cost: The high cost of breakfast for guests without elite status (like Hyatt Globalist) is a point of contention.
• Minor Room Issues: Occasional mentions of non-working room tablets, small slippers, or warm mini-bar water.
• No Locker Rooms by Pool/Gym: While the pool and gym are praised, the absence of dedicated locker rooms nearby is sometimes mentioned.

Sources

1. breakingeighty.com
2. offthebeatenpoints.com
3. reddit.com
4. thepointsguy.com
5. wegettotravel.com
6. frequentmiler.com
7. youtube.com
8. hyatt.com
9. boardingarea.com
10. youtube.com
11. reddit.com
12. onehappytraveler.com
13. milestomemories.com
14. kayak.com