Mandarin Oriental New York

The Mandarin Oriental New York, a Michelin Key Selected property, consistently earns high praise for its luxurious accommodations, exceptional service, and unparalleled views of Central Park and the Manhattan skyline. Perched atop the Deutsche Bank Center (formerly the Time Warner Center) at Columbus Circle, it offers a sophisticated urban escape, though its luxury comes with a significant price tag.

1. Overall Rating & Sentiment

The general consensus for the Mandarin Oriental New York is overwhelmingly positive, with guests frequently describing their experiences as "exceptional" and "unforgettable". Many consider it one of the best luxury hotels in New York City, delivering beyond expectations for a property of the highest standard. While some recent reviews suggest the decor might be considered "dated" compared to newer luxury hotels, the overall sentiment remains highly favorable, especially concerning its views, comfort, and service.

2. Key Highlights

Guests consistently rave about the hotel's breathtaking views of Central Park, the Hudson River, and the glittering Manhattan skyline, which are often cited as a favorite part of the stay. The spacious rooms, particularly for New York City standards, and the exceptionally comfortable beds and pillows are also frequently highlighted. The world-class service, an excellent spa with a 75-foot indoor lap pool, and its prime location at Columbus Circle contribute significantly to its appeal. The design, a blend of modern Oriental and classic New York style, with elegant Asian decor and subtle accents, also receives appreciation.

3. Room Quality

The rooms and suites at the Mandarin Oriental New York are described as modern and luxurious, featuring elegant Asian-inspired decor, a muted color palette, and layered textiles. Standard Skyline View Rooms average a generous 400 square feet, all equipped with enormous floor-to-ceiling windows that provide stunning city or park views. The beds are noted for being "ridiculously comfy" with exceptional pillows. Bathrooms are a significant highlight, considered "some of the best in the city," featuring deep soaking tubs, separate rainfall showerheads, and high-end granite and marble fixtures. Amenities include HD LCD TVs, yoga mats, automated minibars, Fresh toiletries, and for families, welcome gifts for children and bathtub toys. Despite the luxurious appointments, some guests have commented that certain in-room finishes might be "dated" and ready for refurbishment.

4. Dining Experience

The hotel's main restaurant, MO Lounge (formerly Asiate), offers breakfast, lunch, dinner, and weekend brunch, all accompanied by stunning floor-to-ceiling views of Central Park. The Aviary NYC bar provides an excellent selection of cocktails and views in a more casual, yet still upscale, setting. Room service is available 24 hours a day and includes children's menus. While the food is generally good, some guests have described it as "fine" or "decent," rather than "amazing". Breakfast at MO Lounge is à la carte and of a high standard, with diverse selections and quality coffee. A common remark is the "undeniably steep" prices for food and drinks, and a wish for more thoughtful and well-executed vegan options. The hotel's location within the Deutsche Bank Center provides convenient indoor access to some of the city's finest restaurants, such as Thomas Keller's Per Se and Masa, mitigating the need for extensive in-house fine dining options.

5. Service & Staff

The service and staff at the Mandarin Oriental New York are consistently lauded as "exceptional," "professional," "attentive," and "incredibly friendly". Many staff members have been with the hotel for over a decade, contributing to a sense of familiarity and personalized service where guests feel remembered. Guests highlight the team's readiness to help and their genuine welcome, often going "above and beyond" to ensure guest satisfaction, including arranging personalized surprises for special occasions. However, a few guests have reported occasional delays during peak times at the front desk and with valet parking, and some isolated negative feedback regarding the service attitude from doormen and house car gentlemen.

6. Location & Accessibility

The hotel boasts an "excellent" and "prime" location at 80 Columbus Circle, directly across from Central Park and at the gateway to the Upper West Side. Its elevated position on the 35th floor (lobby) and rooms spanning floors 36 to 54 provide unmatched views. There is direct indoor access to the Deutsche Bank Center, which houses numerous luxury boutiques (including Nordstrom), restaurants, and a Whole Foods Market. The Columbus Circle subway station, a major transit hub with several lines, is just steps away, offering easy access to the entire city. The hotel is within walking distance of attractions like Fifth Avenue, Broadway (about a 10-15 minute walk), and Lincoln Center. Its proximity to Central Park's playgrounds also makes it a "fantastic" choice for families.

7. Value & Pricing

As a luxury property in New York City, the Mandarin Oriental comes with an "undeniably steep" and "hefty price tag". Rooms command some of the highest rates in the city, with suites ranging from approximately $2,100 to $4,595 per night. Despite the high cost, many guests feel that the exceptional service, amenities, spacious rooms, and stunning views justify the expense, believing they "get what you pay for". However, some acknowledge that the price is a potential drawback and have noted the presence of resort fees.

8. Common Complaints

Recurring criticisms include the perception that some of the room decor and finishes might be "dated" compared to newer luxury properties, despite the overall elegant design. The food and drink prices are consistently mentioned as being very high, and some guests have expressed a desire for more diverse or creative vegan dining options, as well as a wider selection at the former Asiate restaurant. The shared street-level entrance with the Deutsche Bank Center can make the hotel feel "less exclusive" for some guests. While the spa and 75-foot indoor pool are excellent, spa treatments are costly, and the pool area can become busy during peak hours, leading to a shortage of lounge chairs. Some guests also note that the pool is primarily for exercise and may not be ideal for children to splash around. Isolated incidents of less-than-stellar service from doormen or house car drivers have also been reported.

Sources

1. booking.com
2. oyster.com
3. reddit.com
4. reddit.com
5. michelin.com
6. luxurytravelmag.com.au
7. youtube.com
8. booking.com
9. lajollamom.com
10. internationaltraveller.com
11. timeout.com