Equinox Hotel New York
Selected
Check Availability & Prices
Find the best rates for Equinox Hotel New York.
Check Availability on Booking.comView the official listing on the MICHELIN Guide.
Hotel Details
Location
New York City
United States, North America
Explore More Hotels
Expert Review: Equinox Hotel New York
The Equinox Hotel New York, a Michelin Key Selected property, offers a unique blend of high-performance wellness and luxury in the heart of Manhattan's Hudson Yards. It generally garners positive attention for its cutting-edge design and unparalleled fitness amenities, though some aspects draw mixed reactions regarding value and overall experience.
1. Overall Rating & Sentiment
The general consensus for Equinox Hotel New York leans positive, especially for those prioritizing wellness and modern design. Many guests laud it as an exceptional stay, with some giving it a perfect 10 out of 10. However, some reviews offer a more nuanced view, giving it 4 stars for aesthetic but 3 for the overall experience, suggesting it's ideal for wellness enthusiasts, solo travelers, or couples seeking modern amenities in a trendy location. It stands out as a "luxury lifestyle experience" and a "true escape from the city."
2. Key Highlights
Guests consistently praise the hotel's premier gym and comprehensive wellness offerings, which include access to a 60,000 square-foot fitness club, spa, and a rooftop pool with sweeping Hudson River views. The design-forward spaces, modern amenities, and features aimed at optimizing sleep are frequently highlighted. The hotel is known for its "360-degree, fully-integrated wellness experience" encompassing everything from the gym to morning yoga and spa treatments.
3. Room Quality
The rooms at Equinox Hotel New York are described as plush, spacious, ultra-modern, and luxurious, featuring floor-to-ceiling windows that often provide impressive views of the Hudson River or city skyline. Designed for optimal sleep, rooms boast serious soundproofing, custom blackout shades, precise temperature controls, and all-natural, spring-free Coco-Mat mattresses. A unique touch includes two separate duvets per bed, aiding in temperature regulation and preventing cover hogging. Bathrooms are spacious, adorned with sand-toned, veined marble, and feature large rainfall showers and Grown Alchemist bath products. Mini-bars are notably equipped with health supplements alongside typical luxury offerings. While many appreciate the design, some reviews suggest the rooms can feel "basic" or lack distinctive character despite their quality.
4. Dining Experience
The hotel's main restaurant, Electric Lemon, located on the 24th floor, is recognized for its upscale, seasonal American cuisine, offering both "health" options and more indulgent dishes. It features a buzzy bar and a fashionable outdoor terrace with Hudson River views, described as a "luxurious rooftop oasis." Food quality is generally rated as good to very good, with dishes like crab in ginger dressing, juicy chicken, halibut, and dry-aged duck receiving commendation. Breakfast is also noted for its quality. However, a recurring criticism is the high pricing of dining and drinks, even for New York City standards, and some guests feel there's a lack of diversity in dining options beyond Electric Lemon.
5. Service & Staff
Feedback on service is generally positive, with many guests commending the staff. The front desk personnel are often described as friendly, personable, knowledgeable, and helpful. The staff at the pool, spa, and gym are also noted for being gracious and capable. A concierge team is available to assist guests. However, some guests have reported experiencing "cold" or "arrogant" attitudes from certain front desk staff.
6. Location & Accessibility
Equinox Hotel New York is situated in Hudson Yards, a "glittery" and "trendy" mixed-use development on the far west side of Midtown Manhattan. This location offers a sense of being architecturally and geographically removed from the typical city hustle. Key attractions within walking distance include The High Line Park, Jacob K. Javits Convention Center, and The Vessel. Accessibility to public transportation is excellent, with the 34th Street–Hudson Yards Station just steps away and 34 St. - Penn Station a 10-minute walk, providing access to multiple subway lines and regional transit. A minor complaint is that the area can be quite windy during winter.
7. Value & Pricing
As a luxury hotel, the Equinox Hotel New York commands premium pricing. Typical room rates have averaged around $989.86 USD in the past month, with prices ranging from approximately $698 to $1,217 per night. While guests appreciate the high-end experience, the cost is a frequent point of discussion. Some reviews suggest that dining and drinks are "gut-wrenchingly expensive" even for NYC, and room service is also noted as very costly. Some travelers feel that for the price, they might opt for a more "classic luxury option" elsewhere.
8. Common Complaints
Despite its many positive attributes, the Equinox Hotel New York does receive some recurring criticisms. Common complaints include the firmness of the mattresses (though this is subjective, as others find them comfortable), overcrowded shared spaces like the rooftop pool and gym, especially during peak hours, and the high cost of dining and drinks. Some guests have noted that the rooms, while well-designed, can lack a distinct character. Instances of "cold" or "arrogant" front desk staff have also been mentioned. Additionally, the Hudson Yards location, while modern, can be quite windy in colder months.
