Chebeague Island Inn
Selected
Hotel Details
Location
Chebeague Island Inn · Chebeague Island, United States
Explore More Hotels
Expert Review: Chebeague Island Inn
Chebeague Island Inn: A Serene Michelin-Selected Island Retreat
The Chebeague Island Inn, nestled on picturesque Chebeague Island, Maine, offers a highly praised and restorative escape, earning its selection as a Michelin Key property. Guests consistently laud the inn for its historic charm, exceptional service, and breathtaking ocean views, particularly at sunset. While embracing a "low-tech" philosophy, the inn provides a comfortable and memorable stay for those seeking tranquility and a classic New England island experience.
1. Overall Rating & Sentiment
The general consensus for Chebeague Island Inn is overwhelmingly positive, with guests frequently using terms such as "superb," "magical," "excellent," and "lovely and relaxing." Its inclusion in the Michelin Guide as a selected property signifies an "outstanding experience" across various criteria, including design, service, personality, and value. The inn is seen as a perfect destination to "hit the reset button" and offers a welcoming, soothing haven away from the demands of daily life.
2. Key Highlights
Guests consistently highlight the magnificent ocean and sunset views from the inn's wrap-around porch and expansive lawn as a major draw. The culinary experience and the exceptional, family-like service also receive widespread acclaim. The inn's intentional "low-tech" environment, free of televisions and phones in rooms, is appreciated by those seeking a true escape and a chance to reconnect. Design-wise, the public spaces exude a park-lodge vibe, while the rooms offer a surprisingly stylish aesthetic. Amenities include complimentary Wi-Fi, access to an adjacent 9-hole golf course, a garden, an outdoor fireplace, and free use of bicycles for exploring the island.
3. Room Quality
The 21 rooms at Chebeague Island Inn are described as "beautifully quaint and cozy" with clean palettes and airy simplicity. Each room is individually decorated with unique antique accent pieces and local artworks, contributing to its charming old-world feel. Beds feature custom queen sizes, complemented by luxurious Frette Italian sheets and down comforters, alongside designer toiletries. However, some more recent guest feedback from 2024 suggests that while the property retains its charm, some rooms could benefit from updates, with mentions of "rusty furniture" and occasional cleanliness issues such as "hair on the floor and a greasy mirror." It's important to note that rooms are intentionally without televisions or phones, and there is no air conditioning, relying instead on ocean breezes. Some guests have also found the rooms to be on the smaller side. All rooms are accessible by stairs only, as there are no elevators due to the historic nature of the property.
4. Dining Experience
The dining experience at Chebeague Island Inn is a significant highlight, consistently receiving high praise as "superb" and "exceptional." The on-site restaurant, "The Charles," offers contemporary American cuisine with breathtaking ocean views, and serves breakfast, brunch, lunch, and dinner. Executive Chef Ryan Swarts, a Culinary Institute of America graduate, leads the kitchen, creating menus inspired by Maine's coastline. Dishes feature seasonal, local ingredients, including fresh lobster, mussels, and produce sourced from island farms and purveyors like Second Wind Farm and Chebeague Oyster Company. Cooked-to-order breakfast is available daily for a fee. The Sunset Landing menu on the waterside porch also offers delectable nibbles.
5. Service & Staff
The staff at Chebeague Island Inn are consistently praised for their exceptional hospitality. Guests describe them as "unbelievably helpful," "amazing," "kind," "friendly," and going "above and beyond" to make guests feel like family. Reviewers often cite specific staff members for their helpfulness, particularly for event coordination. The staff's attentive and intuitive nature significantly contributes to the inn's welcoming and memorable atmosphere.
6. Location & Accessibility
The inn is situated on Chebeague Island, a tranquil and picturesque island in Maine's Casco Bay, approximately 3.5 miles long and 1.5 miles wide. It's perched on a hilltop with expansive views overlooking a nine-hole golf course and Casco Bay. The island itself emphasizes a serene experience, free from highways, traffic lights, and bustling nightlife. Accessibility to the island is primarily by ferry, with options including a 15-minute ride from Cousins Island or a more scenic 1.5-hour journey from Portland. The inn provides a complimentary ferry terminal shuttle. On the island, guests can enjoy a variety of activities such as biking, visiting beaches (like Indian Point Beach), playing tennis, golfing, and chartering boats. The island is also noted as a walkable place.
7. Value & Pricing
While offering a high-end experience, the Chebeague Island Inn is recognized by the Michelin Key for its "Value for the Price." Recent average nightly rates for a queen room can range from approximately $278 to $558, depending on the season and specific room type. July is typically the most expensive month to stay, while September offers comparatively cheaper rates. A 50% deposit is required at the time of booking, with the balance due upon checkout. Cooked-to-order breakfast is available for a fee, approximately $25 for adults and children.
8. Common Complaints
While overwhelmingly positive, some recurring criticisms exist. Several recent reviews mention that the rooms, despite their charm, could use updating, with specific mentions of "rusty furniture" and instances of less-than-perfect cleanliness, such as "hair on the floor and a greasy mirror." The rooms are also noted by some guests as being "small." The intentional lack of televisions and phones in the rooms, while a highlight for many seeking a digital detox, might be a drawback for those who prefer these amenities. There have also been isolated reports of minor maintenance issues, such as a "leaking toilet" or a "bag mix-up" upon arrival.
Sources
Google Reviews
172 reviews
Recent Guest Reviews
André Rouillard
These guys are charging way too much. 10/10 location and porch overlooking the water, but the hotel and restaurant aren’t worth anywhere near $400+ per night. Service in the restaurant is excellent (we love Josh!) but the and vibe of the front desk is really off. After asking the for a shuttle ride down to the ferry upon our departure, the front desk saying they’d come get us, and then the shuttle...
Sarah Hamilton
I had a 50 person wedding at the Inn and it was the most spectacular wedding venue. The food, staff, and experience were extraordinary. Nothing beats it.
jolene howard
Lovely lovely lovely spot. The Inn is at the top of a hill and within walking distance from the ferry but if you have heavy bags, call in advance (or upon arrival) to request a shuttle to meet you. The Inn itself is beautifully appointed: outdoor fire for s’mores in the evening, a beautiful coveted wrap-around porch for meals and cocktails, wonderful local oysters, afternoon beer garden, access t...
Nathan
Simply the best meal I've ever had. Green Goddess salad was phenomenal and the Pollock Schnitzel was unique and incredibly flavorful. The summer zucchini was a one-of-a-kind approach to the vegetable, and the unusual combination of flavors worked perfectly. One of the most unique and astounding restaurants I've ever attended. Prices match the setting, quality and ambiance, it is pricey, but it is ...
John Weyrens
This place is an absolute dump. After hearing countless Portland locals rave about the restaurant I finally decided to check it out. The school bus ride to the ferry was a properly downscale start to the evening but I figured the Inn would make it all worth it. Stepping into the lobby is like stepping into the furniture section of a Goodwill Store. The dirty upholstery was ripped and threadbare. T...
Longbow Gaming
Very good cocktails and food. The bar is great and it's a good meeting area for Island community members. I've had some many good times here. The service and drinks are wonderful and the fact you can visit a bar in the Island is amazing. If your on the Island and have some extra money it's definitely worth it.
