Akelarre
Two Michelin Keys
Hotel Details
Location
Akelarre · San Sebastian, Spain
Explore More Hotels
Expert Review: Akelarre
Akelarre, San Sebastian: A Harmonious Blend of Gastronomy, Design, and Breathtaking Views
Akelarre in San Sebastian, a distinguished Michelin Two-Keys property, offers guests an exceptional luxury experience, primarily lauded for its stunning clifftop location, sophisticated minimalist design, and the culinary prowess of its adjoining three-Michelin-starred restaurant. While widely celebrated, some guests have noted inconsistencies in service at times.
1. Overall Rating & Sentiment
The general consensus for Akelarre is overwhelmingly positive, with guests frequently describing it as "exceptional" and "one of the best hotel experiences" in their lifetime. The sentiment often leans towards awe and indulgence, particularly for those seeking a tranquil retreat with world-class dining.
2. Key Highlights
Guests consistently rave about several standout features:
- Location & Views: Perched on Monte Igueldo overlooking the Bay of Biscay, the hotel offers "stunning views" of the Basque coastline and the Cantabrian Sea, providing a "calm and peaceful" environment. Terraces and bay windows are strategically designed to maximize these expansive sea views.
- Design: Akelarre is an "architect's delight" with "exquisite and modern" architecture, featuring clean lines, smooth curves, wood paneling, and rough grey stone. The design is sophisticated yet not stuffy, creating an "air of intrigue and otherworldliness". Thoughtful design choices include key card-operated doors, stylish seating areas, and minimalist rooms that let the outside in.
- Dining: The hotel's connection to Pedro Subijana's legendary three-Michelin-starred Akelarre restaurant is a major draw for "food pilgrims". Many guests consider the restaurant "terrific" and a "sensational" experience, showcasing creativity and deliciousness.
- Spa & Wellness: The "seriously sexy spa" is a significant highlight, featuring moody lighting, black stone, a pool with hydrotherapy jets, a marble hammam, a sauna, and treatment rooms. The spa is seen as a perfect place to unwind and enjoy sea views.
3. Room Quality
The rooms at Akelarre are described as "extraordinary" and "absolutely superior", impeccably designed with high-quality materials and furnishings. They are notably spacious, starting at 50 square meters, with suites spanning a full hundred.
- Comfort & Design: Rooms feature "minimalist interiors with the optimal balance of warm wood and cool marble", designed to maximize ocean views with floor-to-ceiling glass doors leading to private terraces. Beds are reported to be "very comfortable".
- Amenities: Most rooms boast massive soaking tubs positioned before vast exterior windows, while suites elevate the experience with private plunge pools. All rooms include modern electronics like high-end Bang & Olufsen sound systems and Apple TVs. Bathrooms are spacious, with dual-vanity sinks, separate toilet rooms (though frosted glass doors are suggested for more privacy by some), walk-in showers, and organic bath products. Suites also offer walk-in closets.
4. Dining Experience
Akelarre offers a diverse culinary experience:
- Akelarre Restaurant (3 Michelin Stars): This is undoubtedly the hotel's gastronomic centerpiece, consistently praised for its innovative Basque cuisine by Chef Pedro Subijana. Guests report an exceptional dining experience with creative and delicious dishes, often highlighting how ingredients' essences are perfectly extracted. However, some older reviews mention concerns about "too much experimenting with different techniques" and a potentially "dated look" of the dining room. Booking well in advance is essential, as hotel guests are not guaranteed a table upon arrival.
- Oteiza (Casual Dining): The hotel also features Oteiza, a more casual dining option. Breakfast, which can be enjoyed in-room or at Oteiza, is often included and described as "very good" with a "biggest selection we have EVER had". House-made sheep's milk yogurt and well-prepared egg dishes are frequently mentioned. The à la carte service at Oteiza is noted for its attentive staff and delicious Basque dishes, including signature snacks and standout mains like roasted suckling pig.
- Bar: A chic bar and cocktail bar are also available, with the latter receiving "top marks".
5. Service & Staff
Feedback on service is generally positive, with guests frequently using terms like "impeccable", "very friendly", "professional", and "attentive". Specific mentions include staff being "amazing" and "extremely great", with one staff member, Itziar, highlighted for her detailed service and breakfast recommendations.
However, some guest experiences suggest inconsistencies, with a review noting "somewhat stuffy and untrained staff" at Oteiza. One guest celebrating an anniversary felt their special occasion and upgrade request were not acknowledged, leading to a perception of "service misses" and a suggestion for a more experienced general manager.
6. Location & Accessibility
Akelarre is situated on a hillside perch on Monte Igueldo, offering "an unbeatable location overlooking the Bay of Biscay". It provides a "calm natural environment" just 10-15 minutes by car from downtown San Sebastian. While providing a serene escape, guests often find having their "own set of wheels" handy, though taxis are an option. San Sebastian Airport is a 25-minute drive away, and Bilbao, Biarritz, and Pamplona airports are about an hour's drive. The proximity allows guests to enjoy San Sebastian's cultural attractions, beaches, and renowned culinary scene, including its famous pintxo routes.
7. Value & Pricing
While explicit price ranges are not detailed in the reviews, Akelarre is consistently described as a "luxury boutique hotel" and a "5-star" property, affiliated with Relais & Châteaux. Given its Michelin-starred restaurant, stunning design, and comprehensive amenities (including a spa, gym, and private plunge pools in suites), it is understood to be a high-end experience, reflected in its pricing. Guests often view it as a "treat" or an "indulgence", implying a premium cost.
8. Common Complaints
While overwhelmingly positive, a few recurring criticisms emerged:
- Service Inconsistency: Some guests have noted instances of service not living up to Relais & Châteaux standards, with staff occasionally described as "stuffy and untrained" or lacking in anticipating guest needs for special occasions.
- Restaurant Plating/Innovation (Akelarre): While generally highly praised, some diners have found the plating at the 3-Michelin-starred restaurant "unimpressive" and a few dishes to be "too much experimenting" or not tasting "all that great," suggesting that the creativity sometimes overshadowed deliciousness or tradition.
- Gym Size: The gym has been described as "laughably small" with "dated equipment" and no fitness class offerings.
- Water Pressure: One guest noted "not much water pressure in the shower".
- Spa Crowding: The spa, while impressive, was felt to be "slightly cramped" when multiple couples were using the facilities simultaneously.
Sources
Points to Consider
- •While overwhelmingly positive, a few recurring criticisms emerged:
Google Reviews
1,907 reviews
Recent Guest Reviews
Sofia Alonso
We had an unforgettable dinner at Akelarre Restaurant while visiting San Sebastián with our family, and it absolutely lived up to its three Michelin stars. From start to finish, the experience was exceptional. When we first arrived, the staff invited us to tour the kitchen and watch the chefs at work — such a fun and fascinating way to start the evening! Our party of six was seated at a beautiful...
The Global Gourmand
What a wonderful location. The ambiance was exquisite. I loved the tour of the kitchen, and the staff was kind, especially the Mâitre ď. They changed sommelier on us mid tasting menu, and the replacement didnt do a great job of telling us anything about the wine, which was a disappointment. More concerning were the 2 hairs I found in the food and the dirty fork I was presented with on the 4th cou...
Anna
Our experience at Akelarre was absolutely amazing. The food was exceptional — every dish was creative, beautifully presented, and full of incredible flavor. The staff were warm, attentive, and made us feel completely taken care of from start to finish. The atmosphere, the views, and the entire experience were unforgettable. Truly a 10/10 evening — we loved every moment and can’t wait to return!
Karina Christmann
We came here for the amazing view and some drinks. It turned out to be a beautiful and peaceful afternoon. The hotel is surrounded by nature, so you get a nice calming effect from the smell of greenery and herbs. Very romantic.
Marius Fagerland
Akelarre - Excellent food, but disappointing overall experience. Akelarre undoubtedly delivers on the food front - the tuna and hake were particularly exceptional, and the spectacular ocean views combined with the kitchen tour create a memorable atmosphere. Unfortunately, the experience was marred by logistical issues. Dinner started late and didn't finish until 1 AM, which made the final course...
Alice Ho
This is a hard one for me to rate as it is a Michelin 3* restaurant so naturally I am more critical and has higher expectations. But also because I don’t want them to feel pressured by my comments thus it took me a while to submit this review. However I feel as a 3*, it’s better that they accept every customer’s feedback or opinion. Firstly, we had a drink downstairs before the restaurant opened...
About Two Michelin Keys
Two Michelin Keys recognize hotels that provide an excellent stay experience. These properties stand out for their remarkable quality, distinctive character, and superior service that goes above and beyond expectations.
Amex FHR
