Ace Hotel Pittsburgh

It is important to note that the Ace Hotel Pittsburgh, as a distinct entity under that name, closed during the COVID-19 pandemic and reopened in September 2021 under new management and a new name, Kasa at the Maverick. While the Michelin Guide does feature Ace Hotel Pittsburgh, the Michelin Key system was introduced in April 2024, meaning its selection would refer to the hotel's previous operation. This review synthesizes guest experiences and expert opinions from when it operated as the Ace Hotel Pittsburgh and was recognized by the Michelin Guide.

Comprehensive Hotel Review: Ace Hotel Pittsburgh (Former Operations)

1. Overall Rating & Sentiment

The general sentiment for the former Ace Hotel Pittsburgh was largely positive, with guests appreciating its unique character, design, and atmosphere. It was often described as a "wonderful small boutique hotel" that stood out from typical chain hotels. It held an average rating of 8.9/10 on Booking.com and 8.6/10 on KAYAK, based on reviews from its operational period. The hotel was seen as a symbol of Pittsburgh's urban renaissance, attracting local creative and artistic types.

2. Key Highlights

Guests consistently lauded several aspects of the Ace Hotel Pittsburgh:

• Design & Atmosphere: Housed in a monumental, century-old former YMCA building, the hotel offered a unique and community-rooted atmosphere with ornate architecture and a cozier, more handmade feel than typical hotels. The lobby, with its café, was a particularly inviting public space for socializing and working.
• Location: Its placement in the East Liberty district, near Google and Uber's Pittsburgh HQ, was considered excellent.
• Dining: The on-site restaurant, The Whitfield, was frequently praised for its excellent food and fine dining approach within a casual, laid-back setting.
• Staff: Friendly and cooperative staff were often highlighted in reviews.

3. Room Quality

The rooms at Ace Hotel Pittsburgh were described as simple, spare, bright, and sunny, managing to feel both comfortably lived-in and crisply brand-new. They were noted for their creative and unique design, deviating from uniform layouts due to the building's former purpose.

• Comfort: Guests frequently mentioned the comfortable beds.
• Sizes: Rooms were available in small, medium, and large, as well as spacious suites. Even the "small" rooms were generally considered more than adequate.
• Amenities: Room amenities included Tivoli Radios, Rudy's toiletries, bathrobes, hypoallergenic mattresses, and vintage furniture. Suites even featured Music Hall turntables and acoustic Martin guitars. Handmade comforters from a local Pittsburgh suburb added a unique touch.

4. Dining Experience

The Whitfield, the hotel's anchor restaurant, was a significant draw.

• Quality: The food at The Whitfield was consistently rated as excellent, with a focus on locally inspired and sourced ingredients. It offered breakfast, lunch, dinner, brunch, and late-night bites.
• Breakfast: A made-to-order breakfast was served on weekends.
• Atmosphere: The restaurant maintained a casual, laid-back yet fine dining atmosphere. Brunch was described as a delicious and lively experience. The lobby bar was also spacious and inviting.

5. Service & Staff

Guests generally reported positive interactions with the hotel's staff. Feedback often highlighted them as friendly, courteous, cooperative, and helpful. One guest specifically praised the "terrific and fabulous staff".

6. Location & Accessibility

The Ace Hotel Pittsburgh was situated in the center of the East Liberty district, a neighborhood undergoing gentrification and considered well-placed.

• Attractions: It was within walking distance of the East Liberty Presbyterian Church and the Steel City Improv Theater. Other attractions like the Pittsburgh Zoo and PPG Aquarium were about 1.3 to 2.8 miles away, and Carnegie Mellon University was 2.5 km away.
• Transport: The hotel was well-connected, with a bus station (Highland Avenue at Broad Street) nearby. It was approximately 35 minutes from Pittsburgh International Airport, though travel time could double during peak periods.

7. Value & Pricing

While specific "Michelin Key" pricing isn't applicable, the hotel's rates were generally considered good value, especially given its unique offerings. Average weeknight prices were around $92-$143, with weekend nights averaging $139-$182. Prices could fluctuate, with April often being the cheapest month and June or November being the most expensive. Some guests found the rates to be great for the premium experience offered.

8. Common Complaints

Despite the overall positive feedback, some recurring issues were noted by guests:

• Cleanliness: There were occasional complaints about cleanliness.
• Uncomfortable Furniture: Some guests found certain furniture, such as bar stools, to be uncomfortable.
• High Extra Charges: High extra charges for amenities like parking were a point of contention. Valet parking was the primary option, and some considered it terrible.
• Noise: Some reviews mentioned street noise as an issue.
• Service Lapses: While generally positive, there were isolated instances of rude staff or slow service in the restaurant.

Note on Current Status: As previously mentioned, the building that formerly housed Ace Hotel Pittsburgh is now operating as Kasa at the Maverick. Therefore, while this review reflects the Ace Hotel Pittsburgh as a Michelin-selected property during its operation, the current guest experience and offerings will differ.

Sources

1. triblive.com
2. michelin.com
3. michelin.com
4. awardtravel.co
5. gaycities.com
6. kayak.com
7. liveandletsfly.com
8. kayak.com
9. hotels-pittsburgh.com
10. bedandbreakfast-pittsburgh.com
11. pittsburghquarterly.com
12. pittsburgh-hotels.net
13. myboutiquehotel.com