The Roundhouse

The Roundhouse, a Michelin Key Selected property nestled in Beacon, New York, offers a unique blend of historic charm and modern luxury, set amidst the picturesque backdrop of Fishkill Creek and its cascading waterfall. This former 19th-century industrial complex has been meticulously restored to provide a distinctive boutique hotel experience in the heart of the Hudson Valley.

1. Overall Rating & Sentiment

The general consensus for The Roundhouse is overwhelmingly positive, with guests frequently praising its exceptional location, stunning design, and comfortable accommodations. It consistently receives "Very Good" ratings across various platforms, often scoring high for location, cleanliness, comfort, and staff performance. Guests often describe their stays as excellent and memorable, highlighting the hotel's ability to provide a relaxing and artful retreat.

2. Key Highlights

Guests consistently rave about several standout features:

• Location & Views: The prime location directly overlooking a beautiful waterfall and Fishkill Creek is a major draw. Many rooms offer sweeping creek and waterfall views, providing a serene backdrop. Its proximity to Main Street Beacon means attractions, shops, and dining are just steps away.
• Design & Ambiance: The hotel's design beautifully marries its industrial past with contemporary aesthetics and mid-century modern touches. Exposed brick, high ceilings, original wood beams, and oversized factory windows contribute to a unique and stylish atmosphere.
• Comfort & Serenity: Guests frequently mention the comfort of the rooms and the tranquil ambiance created by the waterfall, making it an ideal escape from city life.
• Service & Staff: The staff is often described as friendly, helpful, and accommodating, contributing to a pleasant guest experience.

3. Room Quality

The Roundhouse offers 51 beautifully appointed guest rooms and spacious suites spread across two distinct buildings: The Roundhouse Building and The Mill Building. Rooms are designed with an urban-contemporary intent, featuring modern amenities, custom, locally crafted furnishings, pillowtop mattresses, and luxury linens for an ultra-comfortable stay. Many rooms boast high ceilings, exposed brick, and large windows that frame stunning views of the creek or waterfall. In-room amenities include air conditioning, flat-screen TVs, private bathrooms with bathrobes, free toiletries, hairdryers, and Keurig coffee machines. Some rooms also include seating areas, and the luxurious Penthouse Suites offer an open concept with private decks overlooking Beacon Falls and Fishkill Creek.

4. Dining Experience

The Roundhouse Restaurant is renowned for its modern American cuisine, which is deeply inspired by the agricultural richness of the Hudson Valley and highlights local farms, wineries, and distilleries. The main dining room features handcrafted wood tables, vaulted ceilings, and floor-to-ceiling windows offering spectacular waterfall and creek views, creating a sophisticated setting for unhurried dinners. For warmer months, a relaxed patio offers outdoor dining with views of Fishkill Creek, while the elegant lounge provides a cozy space for cocktails and lighter meals by the fireplace.

The hotel offers a complimentary in-room continental breakfast, which some guests have found to be a delightful start to the day, though a few have described it as basic or "just so so" for the price. The restaurant also serves lunch on Saturdays and brunch on Sundays, with a diverse menu including items like Lump Crab Meat Eggs Benedict and Brioche French Toast. Reservations for dinner are strongly suggested.

5. Service & Staff

Guest feedback on service and staff is generally positive, with many reviewers praising the team's friendliness, helpfulness, and accommodating nature. The hotel maintains a 24-hour front desk to assist guests. While most experiences are positive, there have been isolated comments from past employee reviews hinting at potential issues with favoritism and shift allocation, and some guest reviews noted inconsistencies in restaurant service. The Roundhouse describes itself as a "family-run team" dedicated to a "people-first culture rooted in a passion for hospitality."

6. Location & Accessibility

The Roundhouse boasts an excellent location in Beacon, NY, situated at the corner of Main and East Main Streets, directly by Fishkill Creek and its waterfall. This puts guests within walking distance of Beacon's vibrant Main Street, offering a variety of locally owned shops, dining options, and art galleries. Notable nearby attractions include the Dia:Beacon art museum, which is about a fifteen-minute walk away, and the challenging hike up Mount Beacon for expansive views of the Hudson Valley.

Accessibility is convenient, as Beacon is an hour and a half from New York City by train (Metro-North from Grand Central Station) or about a 60-mile drive via the Palisades Parkway. The hotel offers complimentary on-site parking in three lots, including electric vehicle charging ports.

7. Value & Pricing

Pricing for rooms at The Roundhouse typically ranges from approximately $250 to $312 per night, though deals can sometimes be found for less. While generally considered a good value compared to other 3-star hotels in Beacon, some guests have questioned the overall value, particularly in relation to the basic nature of the complimentary breakfast or if their room assignment didn't meet expectations. Event and wedding costs at The Roundhouse are significantly higher, with venue rental fees ranging from $3,000 to $10,000 depending on the season and day, in addition to per-person food and beverage pricing.

8. Common Complaints

While reviews are largely positive, some recurring issues or criticisms include:

• Breakfast Quality: A few guests have found the complimentary continental breakfast to be basic or underwhelming given the price point of the hotel.
• Cleanliness Issues: Isolated complaints about cleanliness, including reports of insects in some rooms, have been noted.
• Restaurant Service Consistency: While the food often receives praise, some reviewers have experienced inconsistent service in the restaurant.
• Room Assignment Discrepancies: On occasion, guests have noted that their assigned room did not entirely match their expectations or the description.
• Value for Money: Although generally well-regarded, the overall value for money has been questioned by some due to the above-mentioned points.

Sources

1. roundhousebeacon.com
2. tablethotels.com
3. michelin.com
4. wpdh.com
5. roundhousebeacon.com
6. booking.com
7. momondo.com
8. kayak.com
9. agoda.com
10. roundhousebeacon.com
11. roundhousebeacon.com
12. iloveny.com
13. destinationdutchess.com
14. escapebrooklyn.com
15. hospitalityonline.com
16. travelweekly.com
17. exploretock.com
18. apple.com
19. singleplatform.com
20. indeed.com
21. roundhousebeacon.com
22. hotelscombined.com
23. tulletogether.com