The Perry Hotel Key West

The Perry Hotel Key West, Florida Keys, United States, a Michelin Key Selected property, offers a distinctive blend of contemporary luxury and authentic island charm on Stock Island. Guests frequently praise its unique design, serene marina-side location, and excellent service, making it a highly regarded destination for those seeking a tranquil yet accessible Key West experience.

1. Overall Rating & Sentiment

The Perry Hotel Key West generally receives overwhelmingly positive feedback, with guests often describing their stays as "exceptional" and a "highlight" of their trip to Key West. It holds strong ratings across various platforms, including a 9.4 for cleanliness, 9.5 for comfort, 9.3 for facilities, and 9.2 for staff on Booking.com. Agoda similarly shows an impressive overall rating of 8.9, highlighting outstanding service, stunning facilities, and impeccable cleanliness. The hotel has been recognized as a "high quality stay" by the Michelin Guide, earning a coveted Michelin Key.

2. Key Highlights

Guests consistently laud the hotel's design, which blends raw concrete, reclaimed teakwood, and industrial-salvage architecture with local art, creating an "understated luxury". The waterfront location at the Stock Island Marina is a significant draw, offering picturesque views and direct access to water activities. Two waterfront pools are popular amenities, providing relaxing spaces right by the marina. The complimentary shuttle service to Old Town is a frequently praised convenience, bridging the distance to Key West's bustling attractions. The hotel is also notably pet-friendly, welcoming dogs of all sizes with amenities like outdoor showers in ground-floor rooms and two on-site dog parks. Live music at the Salty Oyster Bar & Grill is another enjoyed amenity.

3. Room Quality

The rooms at The Perry Hotel are described as spacious, comfortable, and aesthetically pleasing, featuring a blend of contemporary and rustic furnishings with a beachy vibe. Guest accommodations typically include an oversized private balcony or patio, offering views of the pool, marina, or mangroves. Beds are reported as "super-comfy," and rooms come with amenities such as flat-screen TVs, artisanal bath products, Keurig coffee machines, and fully stocked mini-bars. Some rooms on the first floor even boast private outdoor showers, a feature many guests particularly enjoy after a day on the water. While the rooms are generally well-received for their cleanliness and modern feel, one guest noted thin walls, leading to noise from neighboring rooms.

4. Dining Experience

The Perry Hotel offers multiple on-site dining options, with two dockside sea-to-table restaurants: Matt's Stock Island Kitchen & Bar and Salty Oyster Dockside Bar & Grill. Matt's Stock Island Kitchen & Bar focuses on "American Coastal Comfort Food" with an emphasis on fresh, local ingredients, serving breakfast, lunch, and dinner. Guests appreciate the delicious breakfast options and coffee served here, often enjoyed while overlooking the marina. Salty Oyster Dockside Bar & Grill, located poolside, provides fresh fare and tasty drinks in a comfortable outdoor setting, and is a popular spot for happy hour with half-priced dishes and drinks. Sloppy Joe's Dockside is also mentioned as an on-site restaurant featuring happy hour, Sunday Brunch, and award-winning cuisine.

5. Service & Staff

The service and staff at The Perry Hotel consistently receive high praise. Guests frequently highlight the "exceptional service" and "super friendly staff". Many describe the team as "courteous and welcoming," contributing significantly to an enjoyable experience. Specific mentions include helpful concierge services, with one guest praising a concierge named Johnny for booking excursions and patiently providing recommendations. Shuttle drivers are also commended for being "awesome people" and "personable and very welcoming". The hotel prides itself on providing "genuine, 5-star service to every guest".

6. Location & Accessibility

The Perry Hotel is situated on Stock Island, approximately five miles from the vibrant Duval Street in Old Town Key West. This location is appreciated by guests seeking a quieter, more relaxing getaway away from the "hustle and bustle" of downtown Key West. Its setting on the Stock Island Marina offers "true watermen vibes" and direct access to water activities such as fishing charters, sunset sails, and snorkeling.

Accessibility to Old Town is facilitated by a complimentary hourly shuttle service, which runs daily from 9 am to 11 pm, with the last trip departing downtown Key West at 10:30 pm. This shuttle is highly valued by guests as parking in Key West can be expensive and difficult to find. The hotel is also conveniently located about 3 miles (or 1.4 to 4 miles, depending on source) from Key West International Airport. On-site parking is available, though it may incur a fee.

7. Value & Pricing

While specific price ranges vary based on season and room type, some reported nightly rates for a king room have been seen between $138 and $224. Generally, guests feel they are getting a "luxury accommodation experience, without the luxury price tag". Agoda rates the hotel at 8.7 for value, with guests expressing satisfaction with the reasonable pricing and amenities. However, some guests have expressed concerns about the value for money, citing "hidden fees and resort charges" that made them feel overcharged. The resort fee typically includes amenities such as pool access, fitness center access, shuttle service, in-room bottled water, and coffee.

8. Common Complaints

While reviews are largely positive, some recurring issues have been noted. A significant complaint by a few guests relates to inconsistent water pressure in the showers, with some experiencing a lack of hot water or complete stoppage of pressure. Noise from adjacent rooms due to thin walls has also been mentioned. One guest reported an issue with a sliding glass door not opening onto their patio. Although cleanliness is generally rated highly, there have been some concerns raised about cleanliness, particularly around the pool area.

Sources

1. booking.com
2. agoda.com
3. perrykeywest.com
4. michelin.com
5. perrykeywest.com
6. tablethotels.com
7. michelin.com
8. seasidewithemily.com
9. reservationdesk.com
10. hotels.com
11. booking.com
12. americanexpress.com
13. travelocity.com
14. fla-keys.com
15. thekeysexplored.com
16. blondevoyage901.com
17. perrykeywest.com
18. perrykeywest.com
19. myboutiquehotel.com
20. momondo.com
21. kayak.com
22. reddit.com