The Fish Hotel
Selected
Check Availability & Prices
Find the best rates for The Fish Hotel.
Check Availability on Booking.comView the official listing on the MICHELIN Guide.
Hotel Details
Location
The Fish Hotel · Broadway, United Kingdom
Explore More Hotels
Key Highlights
- ✓Exceptional Service: The staff receives frequent commendation for being wonderful, accommodating, friendly, welcoming, and attentive to detail.
Expert Review: The Fish Hotel
The Fish Hotel, nestled within the picturesque 400-acre Farncombe Estate near Broadway in the Cotswolds, stands out as a Michelin Key Selected property offering a unique blend of country charm and contemporary luxury. It's often described as a collection of quirky hotel houses and huts, providing a back-to-nature bolt-hole with a touch of sophistication.
Overall Rating & Sentiment
The general consensus for The Fish Hotel is overwhelmingly positive, with an impressive overall rating of 9.0 on platforms like Agoda and a "Wonderful" rating of 9.3 from 367 reviews on Booking.com. Guests consistently praise its beautiful setting, unique decor, and the tranquil atmosphere it provides. The sentiment is largely one of delight and satisfaction, with many guests expressing a strong desire to return.
Key Highlights
Guests consistently adore several aspects of The Fish Hotel:
- Unique Accommodations: The hotel offers a diverse range of rooms, including eco-modernist treehouses and rustic-minimalist mobile huts, some with hot tubs, providing a distinctive and memorable stay.
- Beautiful Setting & Grounds: Situated within a vast private estate with views over the Cotswolds and the Vale of Evesham, the hotel's well-maintained grounds are a significant draw, offering peace, quiet, and opportunities for walks.
- Exceptional Service: The staff receives frequent commendation for being wonderful, accommodating, friendly, welcoming, and attentive to detail.
- Dining Experience: The main restaurant, Hook by Martin Burge, is a celebrated highlight, particularly for its seafood-inspired menu.
- Design & Ambiance: The hotel's decor is described as beautiful, unique, and quirky, blending country comforts with contemporary Scandi-style. The various lounges with fireplaces also create a cozy and inviting atmosphere.
- Dog-Friendly: Many rooms and accommodations are dog-friendly, and the hotel even provides thoughtful touches like dog beds in the bar lounge area for owners dining with their pets.
Room Quality
The Fish Hotel boasts 68 beautifully appointed rooms, suites, huts, and treehouses, spread across separate buildings, offering a "village-style layout" within the estate. The design throughout is stylish and contemporary, often described as Scandi-chic, with soothing neutrals and colorful accents. Guests frequently highlight the comfort and coziness of the rooms. Specific room types mentioned include "Medium Rooms" as being cozy and decorated with country comforts and contemporary Scandi-style, and "Hideaway Huts" as comfortable and private. The luxury treehouses feature underfloor heating, en-suite bathrooms, and can be a "bucket list experience." Some rooms also offer amenities like bathrobes, free WiFi, and private terraces.
Dining Experience
The dining experience at The Fish Hotel is a significant draw. The main restaurant, Hook by Martin Burge, is a seafood-focused brasserie overseen by acclaimed culinary director Martin Burge, known for his two Michelin stars at Whatley Manor. Hook offers a luxurious celebration of sustainably sourced seafood, along with options for meat and vegetarian lovers. Guests describe the cuisine as top-class and beautifully presented.
Breakfast is generally well-regarded, often described as delicious and with great choices, including freshly cooked-to-order options. Beyond Hook, the hotel offers light bites and pizzas in its cozy bar and lounge areas. For a unique experience, "Feasting on the Deck" provides an outdoor, three-course barbecue feast for groups. Sunday lunch is also available and requires pre-booking.
Service & Staff
The service at The Fish Hotel consistently receives high praise, with staff described as "wonderful," "friendly," "accommodating," and "welcoming." Many guests note the staff's attentiveness and willingness to go "above and beyond" to ensure comfort and satisfaction. Reviewers have mentioned that "nothing is too much trouble" for the staff, and their "customer service is at the forefront of their minds."
Location & Accessibility
The Fish Hotel is ideally situated within the 400-500-acre Farncombe Estate, overlooking the Vale of Evesham in the Cotswolds. This provides a tranquil, rural setting while still being highly accessible. Broadway village is just 1 kilometer away, offering easy access to its charming attractions. Other nearby towns like Chipping Campden and Stow-on-the-Wold are a mere 10-minute drive, and Stratford-upon-Avon is about 15 miles away. The location is perfect for exploring the wider Cotswolds region, with opportunities for hiking and biking trails directly from the hotel. The hotel offers complimentary on-site parking.
Value & Pricing
While offering a luxurious experience, The Fish Hotel is generally considered to provide "exceptional value for money," with a rating of 8.6 in this category on some platforms. Room prices can start from around £150 per night, including a full English breakfast. Other sources indicate an average price of around $295 per room, which is seen as good value compared to the average in Broadway. The unique offerings like treehouses and huts are often highlighted as being "worth every penny."
Common Complaints
While overwhelmingly positive, some minor criticisms have been noted by guests:
- Breakfast Consistency: One guest mentioned a "disappointing" full English breakfast with lukewarm, rubbery eggs, though the issue was resolved by the staff. Another review noted that the buffet breakfast needed improvement in variety and standard.
- Room Noise/Location: A "Cosy room" was described as small with no view, and a room in the stables block was found to be noisy, especially due to guests chatting near a candy wall at late hours.
- Hilly Terrain: Some guests with slight mobility issues noted that the estate is "very hilly."
- Finding the Hotel: GPS sometimes directs guests to a private driveway, making the initial arrival a little difficult.
- Wifi Performance: On Booking.com, free WiFi received a slightly lower rating of 7.3 compared to other facilities.The Fish Hotel, a Michelin Key Selected property located in Broadway, United Kingdom, consistently receives glowing reviews for its unique blend of rustic charm and contemporary luxury amidst the stunning Cotswolds landscape.
Overall Rating & Sentiment
The general sentiment for The Fish Hotel is overwhelmingly positive, with an impressive overall rating of 9.0 on platforms like Agoda and a "Wonderful" score of 9.3 from hundreds of reviews on Booking.com. Guests frequently describe their stays as "amazing," "beautiful," and express a strong desire to return, highlighting a sense of delight and relaxation.
Key Highlights
Guests consistently laud several aspects of The Fish Hotel, which contribute to its distinctive appeal:
- Unique Accommodations: The hotel offers a diverse and quirky range of lodging options, including luxurious treehouses and rustic-minimalist "huts," some featuring private hot tubs. These unconventional rooms are often cited as a major draw and a "bucket list experience."
- Stunning Location & Grounds: Set within a 400-500-acre private estate with sweeping views over the Cotswolds and the Vale of Evesham, the hotel's beautifully maintained grounds provide a peaceful and idyllic retreat. Many guests enjoy the quiet surroundings and opportunities for scenic walks.
- Exceptional Service & Staff: The staff consistently receives high praise for being "wonderful," "friendly," "accommodating," and "welcoming." Guests appreciate their attentiveness and the "first-class" service, noting that "nothing is too much trouble."
- Superb Dining Experience: Hook by Martin Burge, the hotel's seafood-focused restaurant, is a significant highlight. Overseen by a culinary director with two Michelin stars, it's celebrated for its delicious, high-quality, and beautifully presented seafood dishes.
- Stylish Design & Ambiance: The hotel's decor blends classic country comforts with contemporary Scandi-style, creating a "unique, quaint," and "cosy yet refined" atmosphere. Cozy lounges with inviting fireplaces add to the welcoming ambiance.
- Dog-Friendly Policy: The Fish Hotel is highly dog-friendly, offering many pet-friendly accommodations and even providing dog beds in the bar lounge area during breakfast for guests dining with their pets.
Room Quality
The Fish Hotel features 68 "beautifully appointed" and "contemporary country" rooms, suites, huts, and treehouses, distributed across several individual buildings (The Farmhouse, The Outhouse, The Stables) within its "village-style layout." The interiors throughout are stylish, with a "Scandi-chic" design that combines soothing neutrals and colorful accents, offering "modern, rustic comfort." Guests consistently report high levels of comfort and coziness. Specific examples include "Medium Rooms" described as cozy and "Hideaway Huts" as comfortable and private, with luxury treehouses boasting underfloor heating and en-suite bathrooms. All rooms typically include amenities such as bathrobes and free WiFi.
Dining Experience
Dining at The Fish Hotel is a key attraction, primarily centered around Hook by Martin Burge, a "standout seafood-focused restaurant." Chef Martin Burge, a culinary director who earned two Michelin stars elsewhere, ensures a "luxurious celebration of seafood," sustainably sourced, alongside options for meat and vegetarian diners. The food is consistently described as "culinary excellence" and "top-class cuisine."
Breakfast is generally highly praised as "delicious," with "great choices" and freshly cooked-to-order options available. Beyond Hook, the hotel's cozy bar and lounge areas offer light bites, pizzas, burgers, and local ales throughout the day. For groups, "Feasting on the Deck" provides a unique outdoor three-course barbecue experience. Sunday lunch is also a popular offering, for which pre-booking is required.
Service & Staff
The service at The Fish Hotel is a recurring highlight in guest reviews, consistently earning high praise. Staff members are frequently described as "wonderful," "accommodating," "friendly," and "welcoming," with many guests noting their exceptional attentiveness and willingness to go "above and beyond." Phrases like "nothing is too much trouble" and staff having "customer service at the forefront of their minds" underscore the high level of hospitality provided.
Location & Accessibility
The Fish Hotel boasts an "excellent" and "beautiful" location, set within the 400-acre Farncombe Estate, which itself is part of the picturesque Cotswolds. This offers a secluded, "peaceful retreat" with stunning views over the Vale of Evesham. The charming village of Broadway is conveniently located just 1 kilometer away, easily accessible for guests. Nearby Cotswold towns such as Chipping Campden and Stow-on-the-Wold are within a 10-minute drive, and Stratford-upon-Avon is approximately 15 miles away. The estate itself provides numerous walking trails and a range of outdoor activities. Complimentary on-site parking is available for guests.
Value & Pricing
The Fish Hotel is considered to offer "exceptional value for money," with a rating of 8.8 on Booking.com and 8.6 on Agoda. While prices vary by room type and season, starting from approximately £150 per night including a full English breakfast, guests feel that the excellent amenities and services justify the cost. Unique accommodations like the treehouses are often cited as being "worth every penny."
Common Complaints
Despite the overwhelmingly positive feedback, a few minor issues have occasionally been raised:
- Breakfast Inconsistency: While generally well-received, some guests have noted inconsistencies in breakfast quality, such as lukewarm eggs, though staff typically resolve these issues promptly.
- Noise in Specific Rooms: A "Cosy room" was described as small with no view, and a room in the stables block experienced noise disturbances from other guests congregating near a "candy wall" late at night.
- Hilly Terrain: The estate's hilly nature might pose a slight challenge for guests with mobility issues.
- Finding the Hotel: Some guests have reported that GPS directions can occasionally lead to a private driveway, making the initial arrival a little difficult.
- WiFi Performance: The free WiFi, while available throughout, received a slightly lower average rating compared to other facilities on some review sites.
Sources
Points to Consider
- •While overwhelmingly positive, some minor criticisms have been noted by guests:
- •Hilly Terrain: Some guests with slight mobility issues noted that the estate is "very hilly."
- •Despite the overwhelmingly positive feedback, a few minor issues have occasionally been raised:
- •Breakfast Inconsistency: While generally well-received, some guests have noted inconsistencies in breakfast quality, such as lukewarm eggs, though staff typically resolve these issues promptly.
- •Hilly Terrain: The estate's hilly nature might pose a slight challenge for guests with mobility issues.
