The Comodo Bad Gastein

The Comodo Bad Gastein, a recipient of One Michelin Key, offers a distinctive retreat in the Austrian Alps, blending mid-century design with modern comfort and a focus on wellness. Guests generally provide a "Wonderful" to "Superb" rating, highlighting its stylish ambiance, excellent facilities, and picturesque setting.

1. Overall Rating & Sentiment

The general consensus for The Comodo Bad Gastein is highly positive. It is recognized with One Michelin Key, signifying "a very special stay." Guest reviews frequently use terms like "Wonderful" and "Superb," with high scores for cleanliness (9.5), comfort (9.5), and staff (9.4). The sentiment points towards a well-executed design hotel that offers a fresh, stylish, and relaxing experience.

2. Key Highlights

Guests consistently praise several aspects of The Comodo Bad Gastein:

• Design & Ambiance: The hotel's "super cool designer" aesthetic, blending Sixties modernism and Art Deco with contemporary elements, is a major draw. It's described as fresh, fun, stylish, and creating a cozy ambiance.
• Location & Views: The beautiful location nestled in Bad Gastein offers stunning views into the Gastein Valley, with some rooms providing panoramic vistas. The sound of the nearby waterfall is an added natural charm.
• Amenities: The spa facilities, including an indoor swimming pool with a view and saunas, are highly appreciated for relaxation. Free WiFi and private parking (for a fee) are also noted amenities.
• Breakfast: The breakfast buffet is frequently lauded as superb, fantastic, and offering great variety.

3. Room Quality

The rooms at The Comodo Bad Gastein are described as stylish, comfortable, super clean, nice, cozy, and spacious. Many rooms offer impressive panoramic views of Bad Gastein and the valley. Common in-room amenities include bathrobes, a bath or shower, hairdryer, work desk, and TV. Guests particularly enjoy the large, comfortable beds and the presence of bathtubs in some rooms, which enhance the relaxation experience. However, some guests have noted the absence of in-room amenities such as tea/coffee making facilities, minibars, or snacks. Pillows were also mentioned as being extremely soft by one reviewer, suggesting a preference for alternative options.

4. Dining Experience

The dining experience at The Comodo Bad Gastein receives mixed but generally positive feedback, particularly for breakfast.

• Breakfast: The buffet breakfast is consistently highlighted as "superb," "fantastic," and offering a great variety of options. Vegetarian, vegan, gluten-free, and dairy-free options are available.
• Restaurant (De Leit): The modern restaurant, De Leit, focuses on local cuisine with a farm-to-table approach, emphasizing fresh, organic, and sustainably sourced ingredients. The menu is crafted to be flavorful and creative.
• Bar: The bar offers a selection of classic cocktails and small-batch wines, designed to complement the cuisine.
• Criticisms: Some guests have found the restaurant food and drinks to be uninspiring and expensive. There have also been reports of staff forgetting items during breakfast service, and one guest expressed disappointment with the lack of creativity in the menu and witnessed staff arguments in the breakfast room.

5. Service & Staff

The service and staff at The Comodo Bad Gastein are largely commended for their hospitality. Guests describe the staff as "extremely welcoming and accommodating," "friendly," "helpful," and "attentive". The "impeccable" hospitality is frequently mentioned, with some guests even thanking specific staff members by name for making them feel at home. Despite this, a few reviews point to inconsistencies, noting that some staff members were not always friendly or exhibited poor communication skills in the restaurant. A particularly negative experience involved staff insulting each other in front of guests during breakfast.

6. Location & Accessibility

The Comodo Bad Gastein boasts a prime location in Bad Gastein, described as quiet yet close to local attractions.

• Surroundings: The hotel offers views of the Gastein Valley, and the famous Bad Gastein Waterfall is a pleasant 15-minute walk away. Guests appreciate the gentle walking paths directly accessible from the hotel.
• Transportation: It is conveniently located 1.2 miles from Bad Gastein Railway Station, which is served by both regular and high-speed trains. Salzburg Airport is approximately 60 miles away, with options for train travel or individual shuttle services. Taxis and local buses are readily available at the train station for onward travel to the hotel.
• Activities: The area is a hub for winter sports, and the hotel offers bike rental for exploring the scenic Gastein Valley.

7. Value & Pricing

While precise pricing varies by season and room type, the hotel generally receives a good rating for "Value for money" (8.9 out of 10). Room rates can be around £234 per night for a Deluxe Double Room with Balcony, including taxes and fees. Private parking is available on-site for EUR 15 per day, with e-parking spaces costing EUR 36 per day. Pets are welcome for an additional charge of EUR 25 per pet, per night.

8. Common Complaints

Despite the overwhelmingly positive feedback, some recurring issues and criticisms have been raised by guests:

• Limited Ski Shuttle: A common complaint, especially for those visiting in winter, is the limited number of ski shuttle services, offering only two times to and from the ski station, which can restrict flexibility.
• In-Room Amenities: The absence of tea/coffee making facilities, minibars, or snacks in the rooms has been noted by several guests.
• Restaurant Service & Quality: While breakfast is highly praised, some guests found the main restaurant's food uninspiring and expensive. Inconsistent service, including forgotten items and perceived poor communication skills, has also been reported.
• Spa/Pool Overcrowding & Hygiene: More serious concerns include reports of overcrowded spa and pool areas, and unacceptable hygiene in the pool restroom, with wet floors, toilet paper on the ground, and visible fecal traces.
• Security Concerns: One review cited a significant security breach where a terrace door and safe were left open in the room.
• Paid Parking: The fact that parking on the hotel grounds is an additional paid service (EUR 15 per day) was considered odd by some guests, especially for a hotel of this category.

Sources

1. booking.com
2. booking.com
3. michelin.com
4. michelin.com
5. thehotelguru.com
6. booking.com
7. thecomodo.com
8. hotels.com
9. tablethotels.com
10. booking.com
11. youtube.com
12. marriott.com
13. thecomodo.com
14. myboutiquehotel.com
15. thecomodo.com