Castello di Vicarello

Castello di Vicarello in Cinigiano, Italy, a Michelin Key One-Keys property, consistently receives overwhelmingly positive reviews, often described as an "absolutely amazing" and "unforgettable experience". Guests frequently praise it as a true Tuscan dream, offering a unique blend of rustic charm and luxurious comfort.

1. Overall Rating & Sentiment

The general consensus for Castello di Vicarello is exceptionally high, with guests frequently rating it as outstanding. The Michelin Guide itself gives it "One MICHELIN Key," signifying a very special stay. Verified guests have given it a score of 19.6 out of 20 based on post-stay ratings, indicating near-universal satisfaction. The sentiment is one of awe and deep appreciation for the unique atmosphere and impeccable service, often described as a "dream" or "incredible experience".

2. Key Highlights

Guests consistently love the serene and authentic Tuscan countryside setting, the hotel's character, and its stunning views. The exceptional food, personalized service, and beautifully designed accommodations are also frequently highlighted. Many guests feel more like "house guests than hotel patrons," thanks to the welcoming family ownership and intimate atmosphere. The presence of Uva, the family dog, is also a charming and memorable highlight for many. The two swimming pools, one an infinity pool overlooking rolling Tuscan hills, are also a significant draw.

3. Room Quality

The accommodations at Castello di Vicarello are described as "stunning," "beautifully designed," and "extremely well thought out". Each of the ten suites is meticulously restored, showcasing original stone and brick walls, blending antique charm with modern sophistication. The design is eclectic, featuring breezy linens, Tuscan antiques, period pieces, oriental rugs, contemporary artworks, and Indonesian pieces collected by the owners during their time abroad. Specific room features mentioned include Indonesian daybeds, antique Persian rugs, modern art, intricately carved wooden chests, and copper or marble baths. The "Chiesina apartment" boasts a pergola with exceptional views. One reviewer mentioned their room featured an antique Chinese bed, appreciating the design despite it not being entirely comfortable. Some guests in older rooms, such as Suite Torre, noted the absence of a shower, requiring them to use a bathtub daily, and squeaky floors due to the original features.

4. Dining Experience

The dining experience at Castello di Vicarello is a major highlight, with a strong "farm-to-table" ethos. Food is often described as "exceptional," "delightful," and a "highlight" of the stay. The kitchen sources ingredients from local farmers, herbs from their own gardens, and eggs from their chicken coop, with breads baked fresh daily. The menu, curated by the private chef and influenced by the seasons, features simple, hearty, and traditional Tuscan dishes. Standout dishes include al dente homemade pastas like pici with wild boar, and Fiorentina steak. Breakfast is a light affair with fresh fruits, cakes, juices, and homemade jams. Dinner often has a familial feel, sometimes served at a large communal table in the courtyard, or in a breakfast room with glass walls. Guests can also request a private dining spot in the gardens. The hotel also produces its own wine, which guests are encouraged to indulge in. Cooking classes are offered, allowing guests to learn traditional Italian dishes and then enjoy their handmade pasta for dinner.

5. Service & Staff

The service and staff receive consistent accolades for being "exceptional," "friendly," "approachable," "professional," and "incredibly hospitable". Many guests feel that the staff, including the owners Carlo and Aurora Baccheschi Berti and their three sons, go "above and beyond" to make stays memorable and personalized. Examples of exceptional service include arranging alternative transportation when an Uber canceled in the rural area and even helping to change a punctured car tire and cleaning the car. The welcome is described as very friendly and smooth. The intimate number of suites (around ten) allows for a highly personalized experience.

6. Location & Accessibility

Castello di Vicarello is perched on a hilltop in Cinigiano, nestled amidst the serene beauty of Tuscany's Maremma region. It offers a secluded escape surrounded by gently rolling hills, 40 hectares of organic vineyards, and centuries-old olive groves. This location is praised for being "off the beaten track" and not saturated with tourism. While remote, it is situated midway between Rome and Florence, approximately a 1.5 to 2-hour drive from Florence Airport and Rome Fiumicino Airport. Grosseto airport is 45 minutes away for private flights. The medieval city of Siena is about a 40-minute drive away. Guests are advised to pack a book and relax by the pool, as there aren't many nearby attractions accessible without a car.

7. Value & Pricing

Castello di Vicarello is considered a luxury experience, with pricing starting from approximately 2,000 USD per night. Many reviewers consider it "worth every penny" for the unparalleled experience it offers. However, there is a recurring complaint regarding pricing transparency and attempts to overcharge for food. One guest reported an attempt to charge 250 euros for two pizzas, eventually paying 105 euros, citing the place as "money-oriented".

8. Common Complaints

While reviews are overwhelmingly positive, a few criticisms have been noted:

• Pricing Concerns: As mentioned, some guests have expressed issues with what they perceive as excessive pricing for certain food items, particularly pizzas.
• Room Issues: In some older suites, such as Suite Torre, guests found the lack of a shower (only a bathtub) to be inconvenient. Squeaky floors due to the castle's original features were also mentioned as a minor disturbance.
• Safety Concerns: One review mentioned "no safety balustrade in place" in their room, deeming it "just dangerous" and "not suitable for young kids".
• Minor Discomforts: Occasional mentions of mosquitoes and noise have appeared in some negative reviews.
• Management: Some isolated feedback points to a perceived "lack of management" or "stressful place" in certain negative experiences.

Sources

1. michelin.com
2. tablethotels.com
3. booking.com
4. booking.com
5. ahotellife.com
6. everyday-allyce.com
7. mrandmrssmith.com
8. hotelsabovepar.com
9. castellodivicarello.com
10. hotelsabovepar.com
11. countryandtownhouse.com
12. michelin.com