Banyan Tree Puebla
One Michelin Key
Check Availability & Prices
Find the best rates for Banyan Tree Puebla.
Check Availability on Booking.comView the official listing on the MICHELIN Guide.
Hotel Details
Location
Puebla
Mexico, North America
Brand
Banyan Tree
Hotel Group
Accor
Explore More Hotels
Expert Review: Banyan Tree Puebla
Banyan Tree Puebla, a distinguished Michelin Key One-Key property, offers a luxurious and culturally immersive experience in the heart of Puebla, Mexico. Housed within meticulously restored 15th, 17th, and 19th-century buildings, the hotel seamlessly blends historic grandeur with contemporary comfort and amenities.
1. Overall Rating & Sentiment
Banyan Tree Puebla consistently garners an "Excellent" overall rating, scoring 8.9 out of 10 based on numerous guest reviews. Guests frequently describe it as a "gem" due to its beautiful property, comfortable rooms, and exceptional service. The hotel's prestigious accolades, including the 2024 Michelin Key, Tripadvisor Traveler's Choice recognition in 2021 and 2023, and the U.S. News & World Report Gold distinction as one of Puebla's best hotels, further solidify its reputation for luxury and outstanding hospitality.
2. Key Highlights
Guests particularly praise the hotel's stunning aesthetics, describing it as "gorgeous from every angle" and resembling a blend of a luxury hotel and an upscale art gallery. The terrific and super helpful staff are a recurring highlight, often going "beyond attentive". The rooftop terrace stands out, offering a beautiful pool, a vibrant bar, and panoramic views of Puebla, including picturesque sunsets and distant volcanoes on a clear day. The hotel's successful integration of colonial heritage with modern design and amenities, such as a well-equipped gym and a sumptuous spa, is also highly appreciated.
3. Room Quality
The 78 elegant guestrooms and suites at Banyan Tree Puebla are consistently described as beautiful, large, and luxurious, featuring exceptionally comfortable beds. Each room boasts unique design elements, including antique blown-glass windows, original mosaic floors, period lamps, and four-poster beds, all complemented by beautifully preserved hand-set stone walls. Bathrooms are equally impressive, often featuring spacious layouts, stand-alone tubs (either brushed nickel or ceramic), and rainforest showers, along with robes and slippers. Standard amenities include air conditioning, private bathrooms, city views, a flat-screen TV, free Wi-Fi, and a Nespresso machine. While some rooms offer balconies, minor complaints have included an occasional "sewage smell" in some rooms, particularly in the shower area, and air conditioning that was "not the best".
4. Dining Experience
Banyan Tree Puebla offers a diverse culinary experience with several dining options. Guests can enjoy Bistrot Pasquinel (Mexican cuisine), Cello Cucina Italiana (Italian), and the signature Banyan Tree Saffron restaurant, which serves Thai food on the rooftop terrace. In-suite dining and a rooftop bar for light snacks are also available. The Saffron Thai restaurant on the rooftop is particularly well-regarded. While the American Breakfast is noted as "nice and neat," some guests have found it "unremarkable" and "overpriced," with occasional issues regarding the timely availability of hot food items and "clueless" breakfast staff. The additional brunch option for $15 USD is considered "totally worth it" by some. However, the overall food and beverage prices across the hotel are frequently mentioned as being "super expensive" or "exorbitant." Some also note that the lively atmosphere of the rooftop restaurant, adjacent to the pool, might not be ideal for a fine dining experience due to children.
5. Service & Staff
The hotel's service and staff receive overwhelmingly positive feedback. Guests frequently commend the staff for being "super helpful" and providing "terrific" service, with specific mentions of attentive individuals like Enrique at the Front Desk. The service is generally described as "fantastic," with minor issues being efficiently resolved and a personal touch from staff who often address guests by name.
6. Location & Accessibility
Banyan Tree Puebla is strategically and "very well located," situated on the corner of Boulevard Heroes de 5 de Mayo, just outside the city's historic core. This prime location provides easy access to numerous attractions. Guests can enjoy a short walk to the Puebla Convention Center, Biblioteca Palafoxiana, Museo Amparo, and Museo Casa del Mendrugo. The hotel is approximately a 20-minute walk from the zocalo and Catedral de Puebla. For air travel, Hermanos Serdán International Airport is about 16 miles (25 km or 40 minutes by car) away, while Mexico City's Benito Juarez International Airport is roughly 123 km (2.5 hours) distant. Public transportation options are also accessible from the hotel's central location. The hotel itself is built over historical 16th-century tunnels, adding to its unique sense of place and connection to Puebla's rich past.
7. Value & Pricing
While guests acknowledge that Banyan Tree Puebla offers a "great place to stay" for those "within budget," pricing is a recurring point of discussion. Room rates are subject to additional taxes, including 16% VAT, 10% service charge, and 3% lodging tax. An extra adult or bed in a room incurs further charges. A one-night stay for two adults can start around $159 USD, though average prices range between $224 and $229 USD. October is generally the most affordable month to visit, while November tends to be the most expensive. Food and beverages, including the minibar and breakfast, are often cited as being "overpriced" or "super expensive."
8. Common Complaints
Despite the overwhelmingly positive reviews, some guests have noted recurring issues. The most significant complaint is an unpleasant "sewage smell" experienced in some rooms, particularly in the shower area or during heavy rains, which some attribute to broader city infrastructure issues. The air conditioning has been described as less than optimal. Dining experiences, while generally good, can be a source of frustration due to "overpriced" or "unremarkable" breakfast options, and hot food items not being readily available at the start of service. The rooftop restaurant's ambiance for fine dining can be impacted by children splashing in the adjacent pool. Other minor issues include an instance of a reserved two-bed room not being provided, an uncomfortable cot offered as an alternative, and an occasional lack of room cleaning service during short stays. Guests also suggest requesting citronella candles on the rooftop terrace to mitigate mosquitoes.
Sources
About One Michelin Key
One Michelin Key is awarded to hotels that offer a very special stay. These properties are characterized by their unique personality, high quality, and ability to create memorable experiences for guests.
Accor
