5 Terres - MGallery

5 Terres - MGallery, Barr (Near Strasbourg), France: A Comprehensive Review

1. Overall Rating & Sentiment

5 Terres - MGallery consistently garners excellent to outstanding reviews, with guests frequently describing it as "spectacular" and a "first-class" experience. The hotel has received an average score of 8.7 out of 10 based on hundreds of reviews, with high marks for cleanliness (9.4), location (9.0), and service (9.0). The general sentiment is one of understated luxury, coziness, and romance, making it a highly recommended destination for those seeking a charming and comfortable stay in Alsace.

2. Key Highlights

Guests particularly love the hotel's blend of old and new architecture, creating a "remarkable blend" of historical charm with modern amenities. The exceptional service and friendly, professional staff are frequently praised. Its beautiful location in the historic center of Barr, nestled on the Alsace Wine Trail, is another major draw. The on-site spa, located in an old wine cellar, is also a significant highlight, offering a luxurious and intimate escape. The presence of both indoor and outdoor swimming pools further enhances the guest experience.

3. Room Quality

The 27 rooms and one suite, designed by Jean-Daniel Seltz, offer an elegant, cozy, and very comfortable ambiance. Rooms are described as quaint, comfortable, clean, spacious, and quiet, with plenty of natural light. Many feature exposed beams, blending the historic character of the building with streamlined, modern decor. Hardwood floors and accents of velvet and leather elevate the luxurious feel. Deluxe rooms, for example, typically measure 23-30 m² and include a king-size bed. Amenities often include a flat-screen TV with satellite channels, air conditioning, a private bathroom (some with large walk-in showers and dual vanities), a desk, mini-fridge, and complimentary Gemology bath amenities. Guests appreciate thoughtful touches like fresh cookies and Nespresso machines, along with morning and night cleaning service. Robes and slippers are provided for spa access.

4. Dining Experience

The hotel's restaurant, "La Table du 5," is a significant culinary highlight. It is referenced by the Michelin Guide and holds 2 toques in the Gault&Millau guide, featuring a Michelin-starred chef on staff, Thierry Schwartz. The restaurant offers a modern bistro menu with an elegant, locally inspired concept, focusing on fresh, seasonal, and high-quality products. The wine list is described as solid and fantastic. A buffet breakfast, noted for its quality and local products, is served daily. There is also a cozy and romantic wine bar, bathed in light from a glass roof, offering a selection of local, organic, and biodynamic wines.

5. Service & Staff

The service at 5 Terres - MGallery is consistently lauded as "first-class," "professional," and "friendly." Guests report feeling well looked after and describe the staff as attentive without being intrusive, perfectly meeting the standards of a high-quality establishment. Reception staff are particularly noted for being very helpful. The hotel also provides amenities like 24-hour reception, conciergerie services, and secured covered parking (for a fee).

6. Location & Accessibility

The hotel boasts a "beautiful location in the middle of the historic center of Barr," the wine capital of the Bas-Rhin region. It is ideally situated on the Alsace Wine Trail, offering breathtaking views of the vineyards and the Town Hall. Barr itself is a charming, quiet village, providing an authentic local experience. While Strasbourg is about 29 km (18 miles) away and Colmar about 37 km (23 miles) away, Barr serves as an excellent base for exploring the famous Alsatian villages, with a short drive to many attractions. Strasbourg International Airport is approximately 20 km (12 miles) away. There is a train station in Barr, though it's outside the old city center, making a car generally recommended for convenience. Secure, covered parking is available at the hotel for a fee, and free public parking is also an option nearby.

7. Value & Pricing

Guests often find 5 Terres - MGallery to offer "really amazing value" for the quality of the experience provided. As a 5-star property, prices for rooms typically range, with examples like Classic Queen Rooms around $227, Deluxe King Rooms between $262 and $306, and suites at higher rates. The average price for a weeknight has been around $247, while weekend nights average about $421. March is generally the cheapest month to stay, with August being the most expensive. A city tax of EUR 2.00 per person per night is applicable. Buffet breakfast is available for an extra charge of approximately EUR 28 per person.

8. Common Complaints

While generally highly rated, some guests have noted a couple of recurring issues. The spa area, while beautiful, can become "way too crowded," especially during bad weather due to its small size. Some guests also expressed dissatisfaction with the room size, finding them smaller than expected for a 5-star hotel, although other reviews praise the rooms for being spacious. Another minor point mentioned by a guest was that the drainage in the rain shower could be slow. One review also suggested that the village of Barr itself might not be considered "worthy of a hotel of this quality" by some, highlighting a contrast between the luxurious hotel and the quiet town.

Sources

1. booking.com
2. kayak.com
3. trip.com
4. journeyofdoing.com
5. 5terres-hotel.fr
6. hotels.com
7. hotels.com
8. accor.com
9. booking.com
10. booking.com
11. tablethotels.com
12. accor.com