W Sardinia - Poltu Quatu
Selected
Check Availability & Prices
Find the best rates for W Sardinia - Poltu Quatu.
Check Availability on Booking.comView the official listing on the MICHELIN Guide.
Hotel Details
Location
W Sardinia - Poltu Quatu · Poltu Quatu, Italy
Explore More Hotels
Expert Review: W Sardinia - Poltu Quatu
W Sardinia - Poltu Quatu, a Michelin Key Selected property, offers a vibrant and luxurious escape in the heart of Sardinia's "hidden port." Guests consistently praise its stunning design, exceptional service, and prime location, though some aspects of pricing and noise levels have drawn criticism.
1. Overall Rating & Sentiment
The general consensus for W Sardinia - Poltu Quatu is overwhelmingly positive, with an average rating of 4.5 out of 5 on Marriott's platform and 8.4 out of 10 ("Very Good") on Trip.com. Many guests have awarded it an "Outstanding" 10/10 and Expedia lists it as a 5.0-star property with full 5-star reviews. The sentiment leans towards a "fabulous" and "amazing" experience, especially for couples, highlighting a successful blend of Sardinian charm and modern luxury.
2. Key Highlights
Guests consistently laud the hotel's location, design, and staff as "incredible". The property boasts a contemporary yet distinctly Sardinian feel, nestled within a picturesque natural fjord. The pool and lounge area are frequently mentioned as "fabulous" and "really nice," offering wonderful service, complimentary water, quality towels, and afternoon treats. The breakfast experience is a standout, described as "excellent" and "fabulous," overlooking a yacht-filled marina. Other highlights include a new gym, a "nice" beach club, and the convenient complimentary luxury shuttle service to the nearest beach. The hotel is celebrated for its blend of authentic Sardinian hospitality and understated luxury.
3. Room Quality
The rooms at W Sardinia - Poltu Quatu are generally highly regarded for their comfort and design. They are described as "gorgeous, bright", "beautifully decorated and arranged", and feature "great beds". Many rooms benefit from balconies, which guests appreciate. The cleaning and turn-down services are noted as "fabulous," often including a nightly chocolate or sweet gift. Renovated rooms are particularly praised for being spacious, very clean, functional, and offering luxurious touches like two sinks, ample closet storage, and Bulgari bathroom amenities. Some guests, however, have found the rooms to be "small for the money paid". Room types range from Cozy Guest Rooms to Deluxe Suites and even Penthouses with private pools.
4. Dining Experience
The breakfast at W Sardinia - Poltu Quatu receives consistent accolades, often described as "fabulous" with a "wonderful combination of a la carte offerings and buffet," including a "pasty corner to die for". It also offers "excellent" views over the marina. While overall highly praised, one review noted the breakfast variety as "very limited" despite the good quality fruit.
For other meals, the TANIT Restaurant provides a refined dinner experience with stunning marina views, specializing in fresh local seafood. The W Lounge offers a space for drinks and snacks adjacent to the lobby. CouCou Sardinia on the rooftop presents elevated French-Mediterranean flavors and vibrant energy. Caffè della Piazza is an all-day spot overlooking the marina for casual dining and aperitivos. Guests can also enjoy 24/7 in-room dining. A common criticism, however, is the "insanely expensive food by the pool," with high prices for coffee, coke, and wine, often coupled with cover and service charges.
5. Service & Staff
The service and staff are a standout feature, receiving nearly universal praise with an average rating of 5.0 out of 5 on Marriott. Guests describe the team as "exceptional," "friendly," "professional," and "high service-oriented". Many feel "very much at home" due to the staff's attentiveness and welcoming demeanor. Specific individuals, such as Erica and Luciano at the front desk, Santiago at the beach club, and Sofia at the restaurant, have been individually commended for their outstanding hospitality and thoughtful gestures. The hotel embodies its "Whatever, Whenever" philosophy, offering personalized services from sunrise yoga to midnight cravings.
6. Location & Accessibility
W Sardinia - Poltu Quatu is strategically located in Poltu Quatu, meaning "hidden port," nestled within a natural fjord between the glamorous Porto Cervo and serene Baia Sardinia. The setting is breathtaking, surrounded by granite cliffs, turquoise waters, and a vibrant marina. It offers "great views to the port". The hotel is a 10-minute drive from Porto Cervo and about 23 miles from Olbia Costa Smeralda Airport. While the property is close to many surrounding restaurants and beach clubs, allowing for easy exploration, guests advise that a car is highly recommended due to the hotel's somewhat isolated nature, as taxi rides can be expensive. The hotel does provide a complimentary luxury shuttle to the nearest beach.
7. Value & Pricing
The value for money at W Sardinia - Poltu Quatu garners a mixed response, with an average rating of 4.0 out of 5 on Marriott. While many acknowledge it as a "real 5* resort," some guests feel it is "highly overpriced for the product offered". The isolation of the resort can lead to guests being "bound to the prices around the resort". Poolside food and beverages are frequently cited as "insanely expensive". Room rates can vary significantly, with some guests securing prices around EUR 500 compared to a rack rate of EUR 800, while others observe prices ranging from approximately $409 to over $4,000 for specific room types.
8. Common Complaints
Several recurring issues or criticisms have been noted by guests:
- Loud Music: The constant, often EDM/bass-heavy music at the pool area is a frequent complaint, sometimes playing late into the evening and disturbing guests in their rooms.
- High Prices: The "insanely expensive" cost of food and drinks, particularly by the pool, including additional cover and service charges, is a significant point of contention.
- Room Size & Amenities: Some guests found rooms "small for the money paid". There were also isolated complaints about a lack of air-conditioning in rooms, or amenities like scales and steamers not working, particularly during early operation.
- Payment Policy: The policy requiring immediate payment for consumed items rather than allowing charges to the room account was noted as an inconvenience.
- Miscellaneous: One guest was surprised to be asked to sign a contract for an iron and ironing board, deeming it unexpected for a luxury property. There's also a perceived lack of a dedicated spa, with massage services handled via concierge. Early reviews mentioned some "construction noises at the pool" and "teething problems" upon opening, though later reviews suggest these were largely resolved. An event with loud music extending until late at night also disrupted some guests' sleep.
Sources
Points to Consider
- •Several recurring issues or criticisms have been noted by guests:
- •Loud Music: The constant, often EDM/bass-heavy music at the pool area is a frequent complaint, sometimes playing late into the evening and disturbing guests in their rooms.
Google Reviews
39 reviews
Recent Guest Reviews
Anthony Chubenko
From the moment we arrived, the W Sardinia exceeded all of our initial expectations. Tucked away in the quaint village of Poltu Quatu, the property itself offers a refreshing, modern feel that blends well with the unforgettable landscape around it. The highlight of our trip, however, was the professionalism, friendliness, and charm of the entire staff. Spiro, Aldo, and Christina were a joy to see...
Response from the owner
Dear Mr Chubenko,<br><br>Thank you very much for taking the time to share such a thoughtful feedback!<br><br>We are truly delighted to read that your recent stay at W Sardinia exceeded your expectatio...
Kaitlyn Hilton
Wow I feel so lucky to have stayed here before its open at full capacity. The hotel is immaculate and the staff are amazing. The staff are so attentive and appropriate, its as this they’ve worked at this property for years. I am excited to see this hotels success when it’s functioning at full capacity next season. Although all staff members provided excellent service, some standouts were: Yasmi...
Response from the owner
Dear Ms Hilton,<br><br>Thank you so much for your heartfelt and detailed review! We are truly touched by your kind words and thrilled to hear how much you enjoyed your stay with us, especially the exc...
Victor Pires
Absolutely phenomenal hotel. Immaculately done - every little detail of the hotel is thought out and beautifully designed. The staff was incredible and available to help with absolutely everything. The rooms are gorgeous with plush linens and mattresses. The pool is gorgeous and there is a golf cart to take you to the beach club. One of most exceptional hotels I’ve ever stayed at. 10/10
Response from the owner
Dear Mr Pires,<br><br>Thank you so much for your wonderful review and for taking the time to share!<br>We truly appreciate your kind words about each and every aspect mentioned: providing exceptional ...
Alayna Robbins
We had a wonderful stay and are already looking forward to returning. The staff were exceptionally attentive, kind, and went above and beyond to make us feel welcome. Every detail throughout the hotel felt thoughtfully considered, creating such a special experience. Our room was spotless and beautifully designed, and the pool area offered the perfect sense of calm — like a private resort in the ...
Response from the owner
Dear Alayna Robbins,<br><br>Thank you for your wonderful feedback and for taking the time to share!<br>It warms our hearts to know that your time with us was memorable and that you felt connected to o...
Human S.
So happy to have a new beautiful Hotel on my Paradise on earth island. If I would have known, I wouldn’t even notice the the hotel is renovated - feels like a brand new construction that fit perfectly in the style of this island. The hotel is so nice. The quality of furniture and decoration fits to the high class W represents. The staff doing an extremely good job. You been treated like a welcomed...
Response from the owner
Dear Human S.,<br><br>Thank you for your heartfelt review!<br>Your kind words about our Team and the quality we strive to uphold mean a great deal to us. We are delighted to read that our hotel, thoug...
Rares Jianu
For our final days of the summer holiday season we spent time as a family at W Sardinia - Poltu Quatu. The scenery is amazing, hidden in a narrow port, surrounded by lush greenery, the hotel is a perfect blend of authentic Sardinian hospitality and understated luxury. We spent a quiet afternoon at the pool, where we enjoyed the late summer sun on the comfortable beds, we were refreshed in the cool...
Response from the owner
Dear Rares Jianu,<br><br>Thank you for your wonderful and detailed review of your stay with us!<br><br>We are delighted to read about each and every detail that you are mentioning and most of all that...
