Hotel Christopher

Hotel Christopher, St Barthelemy: A Michelin Key One-Key Property Review

Hotel Christopher in St Barthelemy, a distinguished Michelin Key One-Keys property, consistently garners praise for its breathtaking ocean views, chic design, and serene atmosphere, making it a sought-after luxury destination in the French West Indies.

1. Overall Rating & Sentiment

The general consensus for Hotel Christopher is overwhelmingly positive, with guests frequently describing it as a luxurious, unforgettable, and beautiful experience. It's celebrated for blending contemporary luxury with tropical charm, offering a serene oasis for relaxation. As a Michelin Key One-Keys property, it is recognized for providing a notable stay with high-quality service and a distinctive experience.

2. Key Highlights

Guests consistently rave about the stunning panoramic ocean views available from nearly every room and the hotel's clifftop location. The iconic infinity pool, which is the largest on the island and overlooks the ocean, is a major draw, offering a perfect spot for lounging and soaking in the sun. The Sisley Spa, voted the Best Spa in the Caribbean, also stands out for its oceanfront treatment rooms and extensive menu. The hotel's contemporary design, welcoming ambiance, complimentary buffet breakfast, free WiFi, and valet parking are also frequently highlighted by visitors.

3. Room Quality

The rooms and suites at Hotel Christopher are described as bright, crisp, and contemporary, with many featuring private patios or terraces that offer captivating ocean or garden views. Room sizes typically start around 280-327 square feet. Accommodations are individually furnished and include amenities such as iPod docking stations, DVD players, espresso makers, minibars (with a complimentary non-alcoholic selection upon arrival), and designer toiletries. Guests appreciate the comfort of Select Comfort beds with Egyptian cotton sheets, down comforters, and premium bedding. However, some past reviews have noted that certain rooms could be perceived as small, and in some "sea view suites," a terrace might be absent. Older feedback also mentioned preferences for firmer beds, softer pillows, and luxurious bath towels.

4. Dining Experience

Hotel Christopher boasts two distinct dining experiences. "Le Christopher Coutanceau," a new concept in collaboration with Michelin-starred Chef Christopher Coutanceau, offers an ode to the sea with local, seasonal produce, serving dinner with an eco-responsible approach. For a more casual setting, "La Plage de Chris" provides a seaside cuisine for lunch and transforms into a magical setting for sunset cocktails with DJ sets twice a week. While the free buffet breakfast is generally well-received and described as wonderful, some recent guests have reported a decline in service quality during breakfast and expressed a desire for more diverse options. There was also an instance where avocado toast was an up-charge, despite breakfast being included.

5. Service & Staff

The staff at Hotel Christopher generally receives high marks for being exceptionally nice, accommodating, and attentive, with many guests praising their efforts to ensure an amazing stay. The poolside and lunch restaurant staff are often highlighted for their fantastic service. However, there have been recurring criticisms regarding service consistency, particularly at breakfast, where some servers were perceived as rushed and less personal. Some guests also reported unhelpful or unresponsive experiences with the concierge and front desk, including issues with incorrect reservations.

6. Location & Accessibility

Nestled on a hillside in Pointe Milou, Hotel Christopher offers a secluded and tranquil haven with spectacular views of the ocean and neighboring islands. It's positioned far enough from the island's busier areas to offer peace, yet remains connected to key attractions. The hotel is approximately 3.1 miles (15 minutes) from Rémy de Haenen Airport, and complimentary transfers are provided upon arrival and departure. A significant point for consideration is that while the hotel is oceanfront, it is not situated on a swimmable beach but rather a rocky shoreline. Guests often find it beneficial to rent a car to explore St. Barth's designer boutiques, trendy cafés, and other attractions in Gustavia and St-Jean.

7. Value & Pricing

As a luxury property in St. Barthelemy, Hotel Christopher comes with a premium price tag. Room rates can vary significantly based on the season, with average prices ranging from approximately $1136 to $1730 per night. Low season (e.g., August or July) may see price drops, while high season (e.g., February or January) brings a substantial increase. While some guests feel it offers exceptional value compared to the average hotel price in Gustavia ($1303), others have questioned the value for money, citing service inconsistencies and the cost of food and beverages as points of concern.

8. Common Complaints

Recurring issues and criticisms include inconsistent service quality, particularly during breakfast and sometimes with the front desk and concierge. The lack of direct beach access for swimming, due to the rocky shoreline, is another common point of feedback. Some guests have also found certain rooms to be on the smaller side. Older reviews occasionally mentioned details such as rough bath towels, firm beds, soft pillows, and isolated incidents of pest control issues (cockroaches).

Sources

1. kayak.com
2. agoda.com
3. hotelchristopher.com
4. booking.com
5. booking.com
6. mrandmrssmith.com
7. michelin.com
8. wordpress.com
9. oyster.com
10. access.sb
11. fodors.com
12. hotels.com
13. hotelchristopher.com
14. townandcountrymag.com
15. hotelchristopher.com
16. kayak.com