Four Seasons Resort Seychelles at Desroches Island

The Four Seasons Resort Seychelles at Desroches Island, a Michelin Key One-Key property, offers a secluded luxury escape on a private coral island. Reviews for the resort are notably mixed, with guests experiencing both unparalleled paradise and significant disappointments, particularly concerning dining and service aspects.

Overall Rating & Sentiment

The overall sentiment is polarized. Many guests describe the island itself as a "paradise" and an "amazing" destination, praising its natural beauty and the opportunity for a truly private getaway. However, a recurring theme of criticism centers on the resort's execution, with some reviewers feeling that the potential of the stunning location is "wasted" on various shortcomings, leading to an "unappealing vibe" for some.

Key Highlights

Guests consistently laud the location of the resort on Desroches Island, a remote and untouched coral atoll boasting over nine miles of pristine beaches and clear turquoise waters ideal for snorkeling and diving. The ability to explore the expansive island by complimentary bicycles is a major draw, offering a sense of freedom and discovery. The presence of a tortoise sanctuary and the chance to witness natural wonders like turtle hatchings add to the unique appeal.

Privacy is another significant highlight, with all accommodations being villas featuring private pools and direct access to the beach. The resort's amenities include non-motorized water sports like kayaking, paddleboarding, and snorkeling, as well as unique offerings such as sunrise yoga on the runway and stargazing.

Room Quality

The villas at Four Seasons Desroches Island are generally considered "beautiful," "modern and perfectly pleasant," and "top-tier." They typically include 1.5 bedrooms, an office area with a sofa bed, two indoor showers, a large outdoor shower, and a substantial private pool. While functional and private, some guests have noted that the design, though practical, may not be particularly distinctive or can feel somewhat "sparse" in the living/dining areas. Bedrooms feature comfortable king-size beds, minibars, Nespresso machines, and electric kettles. Air conditioning is effective, and universal power plugs are available. Each villa's sprawling layout and extensive outdoor spaces contribute to a feeling of a "private island within a private island."

Dining Experience

The dining experience at the resort receives mixed, often critical, feedback. Many guests express significant disappointment, describing the food as "lousy," "lacklustre," "disappointing," and "mediocre at best" for a luxury property. Portions at The Lighthouse restaurant were noted as being "tiny."

However, there are notable exceptions:

• Breakfast consistently receives high praise, often rated "10/10" and described as "great."
• The Lighthouse restaurant, despite some criticism regarding portion sizes, is highlighted by some as offering good sushi and perfectly cooked steak, with a beautiful setting, especially for sunset views.
• Private dinners on the jetty or at The Lighthouse are frequently cited as exceptional and highly recommended for special occasions.
• Themed dinners, such as a Creole night featuring seafood curry, have also been positively reviewed for their quality and rich flavors. The main restaurant, Claudine, and the Japanese restaurant, AHI, often receive average to negative reviews. Food prices are generally considered very high.

Service & Staff

Feedback on service and staff is highly inconsistent. Some guests rave about "spectacular" and "amazing" service, describing staff as "polished, friendly, and genuinely seemed to want to make our stay great." Specific praise has been given to breakfast staff for their attentiveness and personalized touches.

Conversely, other guests report "lacklustre" and "disengaged" staff, with one reviewer feeling a lack of "African hospitality." The Kids' Club, in particular, has been cited for disinterested staff, poor cleanliness, and general unwelcoming atmosphere. Housekeeping also received mixed reviews, with some excellent service but also instances of welcome amenities attracting ants for days.

Location & Accessibility

The resort is situated on Desroches Island, a remote private island 35 minutes by flight from Mahé, the Seychelles' capital. This exclusivity is a key aspect of its appeal, offering a true "castaway" experience.

Accessibility to the island is a significant consideration. Guests must take an interisland flight, which costs approximately 494.50 EUR to 550 EUR roundtrip per person and is not included in the room rate. Flight schedules can be limited, and unexpected changes may necessitate a very expensive private charter (e.g., 6500 EUR one-way). It is recommended to factor in buffer nights in Mahé to ensure smooth connections.

Accessibility on the island is managed through complimentary bicycles provided to each guest and an on-demand buggy service. However, the island's expansive nature means getting to some beaches and activities can still involve a trek. The resort is not considered ideal for wheelchair users due to sandy paths and stairs in some accommodations.

Value & Pricing

The Four Seasons Resort Seychelles at Desroches Island is an undeniably expensive destination. Nightly rates for ocean-view pool villas start around $910 to 850 EUR, which does not include a mandated 15% tax and 10% service charge. The additional cost of interisland flights and expensive on-property dining and activities significantly adds to the overall expense.

Some guests feel the high pricing is more justified on such a secluded private island compared to larger, more accessible locations. The resort sometimes offers a "Castaway" all-inclusive package that covers meals and a selection of beverages, which can be a valuable option given the high cost of food. Booking through luxury travel programs like Amex Fine Hotels + Resorts can also provide benefits such as room upgrades, resort credits, and complimentary breakfast, improving the overall value.

Common Complaints

• Food Quality: The most frequent and significant complaint revolves around the inconsistent and often disappointing quality and variety of food, which many guests feel does not meet Four Seasons standards, especially given the high prices.
• Inconsistent Service: While some staff are highly praised, other interactions reveal disengaged or unenthusiastic service, notably at the Kids' Club.
• Poor Wi-Fi: Basic Wi-Fi is reported as very slow, with premium Wi-Fi being an additional cost unless included through booking benefits. Signal can also be absent in certain areas of the island.
• Kids' Club Issues: Negative experiences include uninviting conditions, lack of cleanliness, and disengaged staff.
• Mosquitoes: A persistent issue reported by guests.
• Main Beach Condition: The beach directly by reception is described as being affected by sandbags and seaweed, and can virtually disappear during high tide.
• High Ancillary Costs: The mandatory and expensive interisland flights, along with costly on-island dining and activities, are frequent points of contention.

Sources

1. booking.com
2. jettoajet.com
3. fathomaway.com
4. dorsiatravel.com
5. onemileatatime.com
6. thepointsguy.com
7. fourseasons.com
8. gtspirit.com
9. expedia.com
10. fourseasons.com
11. whatkirstydidnext.com