Badia di Pomaio
Selected
Hotel Details
Location
Badia di Pomaio · Arezzo, Italy
Explore More Hotels
Expert Review: Badia di Pomaio
Badia di Pomaio, a Michelin Key Selected property nestled in the hills above Arezzo, Italy, consistently receives glowing reviews for its captivating blend of historic charm, contemporary design, and impeccable service. Guests frequently describe their stay as a "fairytale" and a "sanctuary of quiet refinement."
1. Overall Rating & Sentiment
Badia di Pomaio enjoys an overwhelmingly positive sentiment, with guests frequently awarding it exceptional ratings, often reaching 9.8 to 10 out of 10. The general consensus is one of profound satisfaction and enchantment, with many feeling "completely in love with the charm" and experiencing it as a "fantastic experience" and a "pure serenity" retreat.
2. Key Highlights
Guests consistently laud Badia di Pomaio for its breathtaking, picture-perfect views of the Tuscan countryside, its peaceful and natural ambiance, and its beautifully decorated interiors. A significant highlight is the stunning infinity pool, which offers widescreen valley views and is often described as a showstopper. The hotel, a meticulously restored 17th-century abbey, seamlessly blends historic monastic elements with sleek contemporary design by Ilaria Miani, using natural materials and local craftsmanship. The property also stands out for its intimate, boutique feel, offering the professionalism of a larger resort in a private retreat setting, along with a strong commitment to a 0-Km food philosophy utilizing ingredients from its own gardens.
3. Room Quality
The 13 rooms and suites at Badia di Pomaio are consistently praised for being "stunning," "extremely clean," and featuring "beautiful interior design." Each room is uniquely designed with calm, neutral hues, Italian cotton bedding, high vaulted ceilings, and modern pieces, creating a restful and refined atmosphere where every item feels considered. Guests can expect plush bedding, and some rooms offer stunning views from private balconies, garden terraces, or expansive vistas stretching to Arezzo's medieval skyline. Modern amenities include air conditioning, minibars with local snacks, and luxurious Bulgari bath products, with all rooms accessible by lift.
4. Dining Experience
The dining experience at Badia di Pomaio's restaurant, Campo Badia, is a major highlight, often described as "amazing" and "excellent." The kitchen, led by a Michelin-starred chef, focuses on "inventive Tuscan fare" crafted from fresh, locally sourced, seasonal produce, much of which comes directly from the hotel's own organic vegetable garden. Guests can enjoy degustation menus of three, four, five, or seven courses, with recommended wine pairings from the impressively stocked cellar. Breakfast is a "bountiful buffet" featuring fresh-pressed juices, pastries, muesli, cold cuts, eggs, bacon, and homemade honey. Dining can be enjoyed on a picturesque outdoor terrace with views of the forest and Chianti hills, or in a comfortable indoor room where guests can even observe meal preparation through a kitchen window.
5. Service & Staff
The hospitality at Badia di Pomaio consistently receives top marks, with staff rated 10 out of 10. Guests frequently commend the team, including individuals like Elena and Mario, for being "so kind and attentive," "professional," "excellent & personable," and truly making guests feel at home. Reviewers highlight their "warmth and enthusiasm," noting that staff "couldn't do enough" for them, providing "24x7 help" with everything from reservations to directions. The hotel's philosophy emphasizes "true love and appreciation for guests." Additional services include a concierge desk, bell staff/porter, turndown service, and laundry service.
6. Location & Accessibility
Perched high in the Tuscan hills, Badia di Pomaio offers a "beautiful location" and a "sanctuary of quiet refinement," providing panoramic views of the surrounding olive groves, woodland, and the city of Arezzo, which is approximately 3.1 to 3.2 miles away. While the secluded setting offers immense peace and quiet, guests note its "remoteness," meaning a car is highly recommended for exploring beyond the hotel. Taxis to Arezzo are easy to book, and the hotel can arrange transfers to and from Arezzo's train station (15 minutes away, €50) or Florence and Pisa airports. The property itself offers various experiences like walking tours, bike tours, and visits to its bio vegetable garden and beehives.
7. Value & Pricing
Badia di Pomaio is considered a luxury boutique hotel, and while its average room prices, which can be around $600 to $1193, are significantly higher than the general average for Arezzo, guests consistently describe it as providing "exceptional value for money" for the unparalleled luxury experience it offers. The price reflects the exquisite design, exceptional service, gourmet dining, and serene, high-end amenities. Prices can fluctuate seasonally, with October being a potentially cheaper month to stay and May being more expensive.
8. Common Complaints
Recurring criticisms are few but notable. Some guests mention the hotel's "remoteness," highlighting that a car is essential as it's not possible to walk to nearby attractions or restaurants. A few past reviews mentioned minor issues with mosquitoes and flies. While the decor is widely praised for its blend of traditional and modern, some who prefer a purely ultra-modern aesthetic might find the traditional elements less appealing. It's also important to note that the hotel operates seasonally, typically from April to October, and welcomes guests aged 14 and older, with no pets allowed. Lastly, the Wi-Fi in public areas received a slightly lower rating compared to other categories, at 7.5 out of 10.
Sources
Google Reviews
143 reviews
Recent Guest Reviews
Elizabeth Williams
What a beautiful boutique, historic property nestled in the hills of Tuscany. Everywhere you look is another stunning view. The hotel itself is gorgeous and thoughtfully appointed. Nothing is too much trouble for the staff who carefully balance friendliness and professionalism expected of a 5 star hotel. Finally, the restaurant was EXCEPTIONAL - we had meals that exceeded our Michelin star meals t...
Response from the owner
Dear Elizabeth, thank you so much for your kind words! We’re truly grateful for your feedback and especially delighted that our restaurant exceeded your expectations — it means the world to our kitche...
Peter & Veronika Photography
Badia di Pomaio is a truly luxurious gem in the Tuscan hills. Everything there from the architecture and design to the warm, attentive service feels effortless and refined. Their own garden full of vegetables, the food, and the atmosphere make it one of those places that instantly leave a lasting impression. We had the pleasure of photographing a wedding there, and every moment felt like a scene ...
Response from the owner
Dear Peter & Veronica, thank you so much for your beautiful message and for the stunning photos captured by your photographer. It was truly an honour and a joy for us to be part of such a special and...
David Perrett
We enjoyed a wonderful short break at Badia di Pomaio. The location is perfect, nestled in a beautiful setting in the hills above Arezzo. All aspects of the property and gardens have been thoughtfully designed to ensure comfort, while not compromising its Tuscan heritage. Breakfast and dinner were both fabulous. However, by far the standout aspect of our stay was the superlative service. Eve...
Response from the owner
Dear Mr Perrett, thank you very much for your thoughtful and generous message. We’re truly delighted to hear that you enjoyed your stay at Badia di Pomaio and that the beauty of our location, the care...
Myles Osborne
Wonderful, intimate resort in the hills overlooking Arezzo. Spent three nights here while sightseeing and every day we found ourselves rushing back early to get more time by the Badia’s pool with a drink. The place is obviously the product of years of planning. It comes through in details like the playful illustrations on the “do not disturb” signs and the exquisite ceramic mugs and plates that an...
Response from the owner
Dear Myles, t hank you so much for your kind and detailed review. We’re truly grateful for your words and so happy to know that your stay at Badia di Pomaio was such a special experience.<br>It means ...
Roro Jojo
Spent 3nights before going to a wedding in Sienna. It is a magical place on all fronts. To start with location, it is private with views and approximate to Arezzo. Hotel, gardens, swimming pool and the farm.. are all super clean, well designed and immersed within surroundings. Food is fresh from the garden and wine selection was super. We loved the wine cellar selection of wine! Staying at nigh...
Claudia Kaml
A Breathtaking Tuscan Retreat with Exceptional Setting, But Value and Flexibility Disappointment Nestled in the heart of the Tuscan countryside, this secluded estate is undoubtedly one of the most picturesque hideaways one could hope for. The sweeping gardens, peaceful parkland, and a private swimming pool create a dreamlike atmosphere, perfect for guests seeking quiet luxury. The panoramic terra...
Response from the owner
Dear Mrs Kaml, thank you so much for your feedback! We're truly delighted to hear that you were impressed by our location and our team. We always do our best to make every guest feel welcome and well ...
