Amberley Castle

Amberley Castle, a distinguished Michelin One-Key property in Amberley, United Kingdom, offers a truly unique and historic luxury escape within 900-year-old castle walls. It is celebrated for its enchanting setting and a blend of medieval grandeur with modern comforts, though some aspects of service and value for money have drawn mixed feedback.

Overall Rating & Sentiment

The general sentiment for Amberley Castle is largely positive, with guests often describing it as "magical" and an "unforgettable" experience due to its unique castle setting and picturesque grounds. It is frequently recommended for special occasions. However, this high praise is sometimes tempered by observations regarding inconsistent service and the perception of high pricing for the overall experience.

Key Highlights

Guests are consistently captivated by the castle's historic charm and its stunning 12 acres of gardens and parkland. The working portcullis that lowers at night adds to the immersive medieval atmosphere. Amenities such as tennis courts, an 18-hole putting green, and a croquet lawn are available for guest enjoyment. The ambiance, with its ancient stone and timber, fine fabrics, and antiques, transports visitors to a storybook setting.

Room Quality

Amberley Castle features 19 luxuriously appointed and individually designed bedrooms and suites, each reflecting the castle's rich history. Rooms are furnished with antiques and fine fabrics alongside contemporary features, ensuring both historical character and modern comfort. Many rooms boast comfortable, often four-poster, beds and elegant, spacious bathrooms, some equipped with monsoon showers or deep baths and L'Occitane toiletries. While most guests appreciate the comfort and unique character, some have found rooms to be smaller than expected for the price or noted minor maintenance issues like mold in shower cubicles or worn carpeting in hallways. All rooms include modern conveniences such as Wi-Fi, flat-screen TVs, and tea/coffee making facilities.

Dining Experience

The dining experience at Amberley Castle is a significant draw, often described as excellent and enjoyable. The hotel boasts two historic dining rooms: the magnificent Queen's Room, with its 12th-century barrel-vaulted ceiling, and The Great Room, a Norman-era space adorned with tapestries and suits of armor. The restaurant serves British cuisine with modern twists and French influences, crafted with seasonal, locally sourced ingredients. A lavish 7-course tasting menu is available, and afternoon tea is a popular offering. Breakfast includes full English and continental options, often praised as delicious. The dining atmosphere is notably formal, with a smart casual dress code required for dinner. While the food is generally well-received, some guests have experienced slow service during dinner or issues with specific breakfast items.

Service & Staff

Feedback on service and staff is mixed. Many guests commend the staff as friendly, attentive, courteous, and helpful, often noting special touches like birthday or anniversary cards. Reception staff have been highlighted as obliging and kind. However, a recurring criticism is that staff can appear "overextended" or "tired and stretched," leading to slow service, long waits for orders, and rooms not being fully serviced. Some guests have described interactions as distant or lacking banter. An "optional service charge" mentioned only at checkout has also been a point of contention for some.

Location & Accessibility

Amberley Castle is set in the picturesque village of Amberley, at the foot of the South Downs National Park in West Sussex. Its secluded location within 12 acres of parkland contributes to a sense of leaving the modern world behind. The castle is easily accessible by car, with free self-parking available on site. Direct trains from London Victoria to Amberley Station take approximately 1 hour and 20 minutes, though guests are advised to arrange a taxi through the hotel as there is no taxi rank at the station. Nearby attractions include the Amberley Museum & Heritage Centre, Bignor Roman Villa, and the historic town of Arundel. While the rural setting offers tranquility, mobile phone signal within the castle can be limited, though Wi-Fi is provided.

Value & Pricing

Amberley Castle is considered a luxury property with pricing to match. Room rates can be steep, with overnight stays starting from around £359, and packages including dining can exceed £1000 for two nights. While many find the unique experience worth the cost for special occasions, some guests have felt that the prices are "frankly steep" and that the value received, particularly concerning room size or service, does not always align with what one might expect for comparable luxury hotel rates in, for instance, London. It is generally viewed as a one-off escape rather than a regular retreat.

Common Complaints

• Service Inconsistencies: The most common complaint revolves around slow or overstretched service, leading to long waits for food and drinks, and occasional lapses in room servicing.
• Value for Money: Despite the unique setting, some guests question whether the high price point is always justified by the overall experience, especially when compared to the size of some rooms or service levels.
• Room Maintenance: Isolated reports mention minor issues like the start of mold in shower sealant, shower heads needing descaling, or worn carpeting in certain areas.
• Mobile Signal: The remote location means mobile phone signal can be poor or non-existent within the castle, though Wi-Fi is available.
• Lack of Guided History: Some visitors expressed a desire for more organized historical walks or talks about the castle's extensive past.

Sources

1. winetravelandsong.com
2. booking.com
3. amberleycastle.co.uk
4. michelin.com
5. booking.com
6. thewanderingpassport.net
7. celticcastles.com
8. manorcastles.com
9. relaischateaux.com
10. manorcastles.com
11. hotels.com
12. amberleycastle.co.uk
13. expedia.com
14. amberleycastle.co.uk
15. footprintsandmemories.com
16. crazyaboutcastles.com
17. rome2rio.com
18. amberleycastle.co.uk